Pound for Pound top 4

[thegreatone1]

Calzaghe
Pacquaio
Mayweather
Cotto

[Left Hook Tua]

i think the top four are pretty clear here; lets look at their last 4 fights and see if we can agree on any sort of order
my order

1. Calzaghe - hopkins(hall of famer), kessler (undefeated unified champ), manfredo( contender at best) , lacy(undefeated champion)
2. Pacquiao - marquez(tough mexican champ in his prime) barrera(old guy should have been retired but HOFer) solis(is he even a fighter anymore) morales(see barrera)
3. Israel Vazquez- Rafael Marquez in 3 battles, won 2 of 3 battles and the war, Johnny gonzales (badass mexican)
4. Floyd Mayweather - Ricky Hatton (140 pound champ) OLDH (154 lb paper titlist) Zab Judah (contender), Carlos Baldomir (the luckiest fighter ever)

by the way it's also funny how you only list the last 4 fighters on their resume......

why not 5? or 6? or even the last 10 fighters they fought?

[ElGranLuchador]

great to see ppl giving vasquez his due in the top 4
the ring ******s put him at 6 i believe

[Left Hook Tua]

great to see ppl giving vasquez his due in the top 4
the ring ******s put him at 6 i believe

unfortunately it's on a list that has calzaghe #1. kinda loses credibility.

[JoartCC]

Pound for pound isn't given to cowards who does not fight the best nor to punks who pisses on their pants.

Anybody who has Fake Floyd as p4p no.1 must have been brought up to admire cowards and undignified punks.

[dustybin]

You cant have it both ways if you want to rate your fighters as great then when they lose in their own countries under their own rules credit has to be given.I dont think there is anything between Mayweather and Calzaghe,you could make a case for either fighter as the best on the planet.

[MakeDamnSure]

The best match-up for Joe was Bhop..
The ebst match-up for Pac was Marquez

The best match-up for Floyd was Cotto and Margarito and he chose a smaller Hatton and rematching a fading Oscar..

1. Pac/ Joe
2. Cotto (After he KO Marg)
3. Floyd (due to inactivity and rematching a Shot Oscar)

[flodistheshizle]

The best match-up for Joe was Bhop..
The ebst match-up for Pac was Marquez

The best match-up for Floyd was Cotto and Margarito and he chose a smaller Hatton and rematching a fading Oscar..

1. Pac/ Joe
2. Cotto (After he KO Marg)
3. Floyd (due to inactivity and rematching a Shot Oscar)

Pac #1 for getting two gifts against Marquez and beating a washed up Morales and Barrera (the rematch)?ROFL


You say Floyd is a coward and fought a smaller Hatton.

and a old Delahoya.



But how old is Marquez,How old was Barrera in the rematch?
Was `nt Delahoya bigger then Floyd?Wheres the "Oscar is fighting a smaller man?You a clown.

If pacqiauo is so brave why is`nt he fighting Joan Guzman ,Zaheer Raheem
and other young prime fighters as opposed to a 34 year old washed up Barrera,An old Marquez who beat his ass twice,And a washed up Morales.


Now hes going after the weakest title holder at lightweight and you call Mayweather a coward.


When is your counterfiet Mexican asassin going to take a fighter whose not old or has pulse?

[pelonxsoldier28]

i stopped reading when he put cal no1.

i'd have to agree. that fight was ****ty, joe should stay where he's at on the p4p list

[pbftxrs316]

floyd-5 division champion in 11 years-skillwise. none of the rest ****s with him. no competition. he's p4p number one until he retires or loses, and he ain't losing, trust me.
pac-amazing workrate, and beating 3 future hall of famers imo.
joe-amazing workrate, and beating 2 undefated monsters and a legend who fought to a close fight. joe is also a 2 division champion, an dis still undefeated.
cotto-undefated lion who is making his name bigger in the ww division and getting better and better, and him beating shane mosley, puts him up there imo. he has a heart of a lion.