Oscar was the easiest defense either Joe or 'Nard ever took

[Degsy]

Bernard Hopkins TKO'ing De La Hoya at 160 is as impressive as anything Calzaghe has done in his entire career.

How can Calzaghe's fans even make such absurd threads?

Mario Veit (not once, but twice)
Robin Reid (SPLIT DECISION)
David Starie
Tocker Podswell

This is laughable. Is that murderers row or what??

The remark is probably going a bit too far but a prime Reid would have ****d Oscar, yet Joe beat him with a Broken Hand from round 6 onwards.
Claiming Oscar as a great is valid at 147, perhaps even 154 but 160 no way.

[VERSION1 (V1)]

Peter manfredo jr

[SupremeElectron]

Robin Reid would have ****d Oscar? You must be talking sexually.

[FRKO]

Rob Reid would have smashed Oscar to bits. Easy.

[SupremeElectron]

I mean, you do realize Reid lost to Sugar Boy Malinga years before battling Calzaghe?

**** Oscar?

[FRKO]

I mean, you do realize Reid lost to Sugar Boy Malinga years before battling Calzaghe?

**** Oscar?

Even Sturm ****d Oscar.

[Left Hook Tua]

Claiming Oscar as a great is valid at 147, perhaps even 154 but 160 no way.

what??? didn't you see oscar dominate felix sturm and take his wbo belt???

[moofo]

what the hell is Calzaghe doing? Tarver was coming off wins over RJ and Johnson..

Hopkins is 43 and NOW instead staying at 168, to face the prime guys that are moving up there..
Joe is going after B hop. please, your a biased hypocrite

The biasedness is that Hopkins is lauded as a "Legend" yet has achieved nothing more than Calzaghe and I would pick quite a few guys who Calzaghe fought over Hopkins weak resume and even Hopkins himself.
As for Joe's legacy I never said it was great did I?
He joins a long list of fighters who from the last 20-30 years will always be asked the question....WHAT IF???
That list includes Bernard Hopkins , Roy Jones Junior , Sven Ottke , Joe Calzaghe , Floyd Mayweather , Rid**** Bowe , Ike Ibeabuchi , Naseem Hamed etc etc etc etc.....
THINK before you ASSUME.

[C'MONMANG']

The biasedness is that Hopkins is lauded as a "Legend" yet has achieved nothing more than Calzaghe and I would pick quite a few guys who Calzaghe fought over Hopkins weak resume and even Hopkins himself.
As for Joe's legacy I never said it was great did I?
He joins a long list of fighters who from the last 20-30 years will always be asked the question....WHAT IF???
That list includes Bernard Hopkins , Roy Jones Junior , Sven Ottke , Joe Calzaghe , Floyd Mayweather , Rid**** Bowe , Ike Ibeabuchi , Naseem Hamed etc etc etc etc.....
THINK before you ASSUME.

Sorry pal. But you cannot compare Manfredo, Lacy and Kessler to

Trinidad, Winky and Tarver...


sorry cant be done.

[moofo]

Sorry pal. But you cannot compare Manfredo, Lacy and Kessler to

Trinidad, Winky and Tarver...


sorry cant be done.

Eubank , Reid (Prime) , Kessler would beat all 3.
I'd also Pick Lacy to beat Trinidad , possibly Winky his old sparring partner who prepared Lacy for Calzaghe.