Who on this list beats everyone else on this list?

[RichCCFC]

tszyu would finish them all, hes the best 140 pounder ever

That's who I voted for too.

[Johnny Rebel]

De La Hoya beat Sweet Pea at WW and would beat him just as easy at 140. Tszyu, Pryor and Mayweather would also beat Pea at 140, as would many others not on this list. Whitaker may have been the most boring fighter ever with little power. Pea should have joined the track team since he liked to run so much.

[Silencers]

De La Hoya beat Sweet Pea at WW and would beat him just as easy at 140. Tszyu, Pryor and Mayweather would also beat Pea at 140, as would many others not on this list. Whitaker may have been the most boring fighter ever with little power. Pea should have joined the track team since he liked to run so much.

How many Whitaker fights have you actually watched? The DLH fight was close when Whitaker was arguably past his prime. He was a defensive master, even better than James Toney IMO. And his fights weren't always boring, I've never seen him 'run', he used lateral movement and sometimes elected to stand and trade with an opponent while picking off shots with his gloves.

[Pullcounter]

its between whitaker, pryor, mosley, and floyd. If I had to chose I might pick Mosley.

[Steak]

That's who I voted for too.

Tszyu folded under pressure fighters like Phillips and Hatton. If he folded against them, what makes you think he could beat a prime Chavez or Pryor?

How many Whitaker fights have you actually watched? The DLH fight was close when Whitaker was arguably past his prime. He was a defensive master, even better than James Toney IMO. And his fights weren't always boring, I've never seen him 'run', he used lateral movement and sometimes elected to stand and trade with an opponent while picking off shots with his gloves.

I never really understood that either. Pernell was actually a pretty consistant fighter in the ring. Hell, a lot of the time he would pressure his opponents. If I remember right, he was even pressuring the huge 154lber Julio Cesar Vasquez in that fight...

and I also remember him throwing a LOT of punches in the Nelson fight...Although oyu could say he did a little bit of running in that fight. Never understood why people called Pernell a runner...he didnt do it often.

[Hagler★]

im sayin its hawk time

[Hagler★]

i cant believe mayweather is winning this has nut hugging and knob slobbing become the order of the day on Boxing Scene. how many people voting hav seen these guys fight?

[tredh]

How many Whitaker fights have you actually watched? The DLH fight was close when Whitaker was arguably past his prime. He was a defensive master, even better than James Toney IMO. And his fights weren't always boring, I've never seen him 'run', he used lateral movement and sometimes elected to stand and trade with an opponent while picking off shots with his gloves.

That is not arguable Whitaker for sure past him prime and on the down side of his career.

[Brockton Lip]

i cant believe mayweather is winning this has nut hugging and knob slobbing become the order of the day on Boxing Scene. how many people voting hav seen these guys fight?

Wow I didn't even know he was winning. Thats messed up. Thats what happens when a thread like this is posted in the Non Stop Boxing section. They see the Gatti fight and think Mayweather is a god. Alot of fighters could've done that to Gatti that night. Pryor would've stopped him much earlier than Floyd did. Whitaker wouldn't have gotten hit, etc.

[Boxinguru]

That's a tough call... It's between Sweat Pea, Pryor, & Floyd...

I could see Pryor beating Sweat Pea but struggling with Floyd (undecided about the winner of that one)

I could see Sweat Pea beating Floyd by a SD

You can't just say Sweat Pea would have beaten everyone on that list...