Who on this list beats everyone else on this list?

[QuCongee]

Where are Chavez and Duran??

Like i said, i left duran out on purpose because most people would obviously pick him. Though i'm not sure personally..

JCC, i think loses to half the list at 140 lbs.

[pbftxrs316]

floyd takes this one. i always said his prime weight was 140 imo, and at this weight, he was too much of a brilliant killer to lose to anyone on that list. whitaker would have given him the best competition imo but floyd is too methodical a fighter for sweet pea. pryor would bring a fight to floyd but floyd is too fast for him and too technically sound for aaron. floyd beats everybody on the list, everybody.

[tyson]

floyd takes this one. i always said his prime weight was 140 imo, and at this weight, he was too much of a brilliant killer to lose to anyone on that list. whitaker would have given him the best competition imo but floyd is too methodical a fighter for sweet pea. pryor would bring a fight to floyd but floyd is too fast for him and too technically sound for aaron. floyd beats everybody on the list, everybody.

You are not even remotely credible concerning any issue like this.

[Steak]

Like i said, i left duran out on purpose because most people would obviously pick him. Though i'm not sure personally..

JCC, i think loses to half the list at 140 lbs.

really? I think Chavez would have a great chance to beat them all, except maybe Whitaker and De La Hoya...Mayweather...eh maybe, it would be interesting.

Normally I would pick Whitaker, but I think Pryor would give him hell. Pryor never did let up in a fight, and Whitaker doesnt exactly have a ton of firepower....Im not sure he could hold off Pryor, Pryor might have outworked him over 12 rounds.

De La Hoya seems to be overlooked here...he didnt have a long run at 140, but he was a beast at the lighter weights, people seem to forget about that. and the two fights he did have at 140 he dominated in...against an unbeaten Miguel Gonzalez who was coming off a long number of consecutive title defences at 135, and an old, but still very good, Chavez.

Honestly, I dont think there is a real winner out of all those guys. Pryor comes close, but I think that he left himself way too open, and guys that could absorb punishment well and hit hard themselves could have taken advantage of that. Chavez was a surgeon and could land flush shots consistantly thoughout a fight and break his opponent down, I think he could do a number on Pryor in an outstanding fight where he would come on and stop him in the later rounds, although losing the beginning ones. Another guy that could have beat him is De La Hoya, who was a huge puncher at the lower weights, although strangely enough his chin wasnt as sturdy as it was at heigher weights...

Mosley just confuses me, and I will say right now that I havent seen enough of him at his lower weights to judge how he would do against the other guys. Aint gonna try to judge something when I dont know a ton about it. I dont recall him ever fighting at 140 at all, but Im sure he would have done fine there...

[pbftxrs316]

You are not even remotely credible concerning any issue like this.

worry about yourself little girl, and not me. you're in no position to determine my credibility boy. i gave my opinion, and that's it. don't worry about my username, read the ****ing post and that's it. by the way, who did you pick, because i'll be more than happy to explain to you why your pick is wrong to me, and i'll give examples and everything. i have all of pernell's fights, floyd fights, and have seen many pryor fights, and again, i guarantee you, mayweather defeats them both, as well as everybody on that list.

stop bitching because somebody picked floyd, and you can't stand him. so you try to bash me for that reason. stop hating on mayweather little boy.

[RichCCFC]

If you like it or not Mayweather is close to Whitaker prime for prime.

It would be ****** to think otherwise.

[tyson]

worry about yourself little girl, and not me. you're in no position to determine my credibility boy. i gave my opinion, and that's it. don't worry about my username, read the ****ing post and that's it. by the way, who did you pick, because i'll be more than happy to explain to you why your pick is wrong to me, and i'll give examples and everything. i have all of pernell's fights, floyd fights, and have seen many pryor fights, and again, i guarantee you, mayweather defeats them both, as well as everybody on that list.

stop bitching because somebody picked floyd, and you can't stand him. so you try to bash me for that reason. stop hating on mayweather little boy.

I picked Pryor.

Floyd is a god to you. That's why you are not credible in issues like this.
You say that Floyd would hands down beat Whitaker decisively

Pryor does exactly what Floyd doesn't like. If you think Castillo was tough for Mayweather, oh **** what a night he would have against Pryor.
Or Duran.

I don't hate Mayweather. His personality is not to my taste, as he just can't stand up for himself, but his boxing is extraordinary indeed.

[raysan]

Ya Chavez should be up there off his performace against Meldrick alone. Castillo gave Mayweather problems, and Castillo was lesser version of Chavez, or as Mayweather called Mosley just a "sparring partner", which Castillo was for JCC. Chavez may have been better at 135, but he isnt an easy fight for anybody at 140 if he is in his prime.

[aussieboxer2320]

tszyu would finish them all, hes the best 140 pounder ever

[J_CON]

Mosley never fought at 140. He went from 135 to 147.