BoxingScene's New Pound-For-Pound List

[sterling]

lol well not the best list but meh

[PRboxingfan]

I cannot agree with a tie for #1. It's like you tried to please all the blind boxing fans by putting Pac up where PBF should be by himself. Floyd is heads and shoulders above everyone else in boxing...PERIOD.

I have Manny at #3, just where he was prior to the Marquez fight (which was a close fight and I thought Manny lost). I didn't move any fighters around because the fight was so close that it would be undeserved.

BTW, Mijares?!?! Are you serious? He's not even the best 115 pounder and you have him in the top 10 P4P? There are plenty more deserving fighters out there (like Montiel, coming off the impressive Castillo victory, Pavlik, Hatton, and even Joan Guzman are more deserving).

1. PBF
2. Calzaghe
3. Manny
4. B-Hop
5. JMM
6. Cotto
7. Izzy Vazquez
8. Hatton
9. Rafa Marquez
10. Calderon

[beauty]

Pac is not number 1 right now. However, I agree with the points he made about Floyd. He needs to devote himself to making a quality fight and not just being a star. If he doesn't do more, he may lose the number one placement on the bogus list anyway.

I love Floyd, but there are some darn good fights he can make and they do not include Oscar or Big Show.

[PoetryInMotion]

Pac is not number 1 right now. However, I agree with the points he made about Floyd. He needs to devote himself to making a quality fight and not just being a star. If he doesn't do more, he may lose the number one placement on the bogus list anyway.

I love Floyd, but there are some darn good fights he can make and they do not include Oscar or Big Show.

I agree. Couldn't have said it better myself.

[brooklyn kid]

LMAO at boxingscene.com p4p list

For Mayweather

"upcoming bouts: mayweather beats de la hoya ll scheduled for...."

[PeterinMI]

I don't like fighters being tied for the number 1 spot on the pound for pound list. There should be a consensus number 1 and a number 2.

I agree. A tie is a chicken*&^% way out. Make a call. Even if you are wrong it is irrelevant. Show some courage.

I don't think the upcoming schedule is relevant for Floyd. It should be up to this point not who is coming. This list seems to be a bit too forward thinking for me.

Anyway an interesting read.

[Piper the Great]

LMAO at boxingscene.com p4p list

For Mayweather

"upcoming bouts: mayweather beats de la hoya ll scheduled for...."

i noticed that too. lmao

honestly i have pacman over pbf b/c pbf doesnt put his skills to the test. he really needs to step up his level of competition.

[sitai]

floyd fought 3 months ago!!!
its not like he's been gone long enough to warrant this
especially seeing as the writer stated himseld that he thought manny lost!!
it doesn't make any sense
in no way shape or form are they equal as a matter of fact i have calzaghe above pacman right now

[Sinisterevo]

I dont see how Pac moves to first with a loss to Marquez...

[J_CON]

Very accurate list