Is Miranda in top 10 at SMW?

**Silencers** · 03-06-2008, 11:47 PM

I have him just inside my top 10.

**Dick-Sucker** · 03-06-2008, 11:47 PM

Originally posted by silencers98

I have him just inside my top 10.

Fair enough mate.

Yeh with myn im inclined to have him in there, but its touch and go.

I have to move Bika out, so i would rather Miranda at 11.

**Pantera2000** · 03-06-2008, 11:48 PM

Originally posted by Ultimateboxa

All i can see is a win over Allan Green. Apart from that he hasn't done much at SMW.

So is he worthy of top 10 rankings?

OK... you voted NO. I voted top 5. Throw those out.
Now we will see how WAY off your opinion is.

How Miranda is not a top 10 SWM is crazy! Arguably top 5 (See *********.com rankings)!

**Dick-Sucker** · 03-06-2008, 11:49 PM

Originally posted by Pantera2000

OK... you voted NO. I voted top 5. Throw those out.
Now we will see how WAY off your opinion is.

How Miranda is not a top 10 SWM is crazy! Arguably top 5 (See *********.com rankings)!

Dude you are the biggest Miranda nut hugger i know. No offence, but it makes me not think your opinion is credible when talking about him. When talking about other fighters i think your credible, just not when talking about Miranda...............

**Silencers** · 03-06-2008, 11:50 PM

Miranda has only 2 fights at super middleweight, putting him in my top 10 is already a stretch, he has beaten David Banks and Henry Porras, not exactly world beaters.

**Pantera2000** · 03-06-2008, 11:52 PM

Originally posted by Ultimateboxa

Dude you are the biggest Miranda nut hugger i know. No offence, but it makes me not think your opinion is credible when talking about him. When talking about other fighters i think your credible, just not when talking about Miranda...............

I think he is top 5. If that is sooo crazy then you tell me why he is ranked:
WBC#5
WBA#6
IBF#7
WBO#10
*********#6
ESPN#9

No way he is NOT Top 10!

**Mike_Dee** · 03-06-2008, 11:52 PM

Although Miranda is a "name", he is not a top ten fighter at 68 based on his resume at 68 thus far.

**Dick-Sucker** · 03-06-2008, 11:55 PM

Originally posted by Pantera2000

I think he is top 5. If that is sooo crazy then you tell me why he is ranked:
WBC#5
WBA#6
IBF#7
WBO#10
*********#6
ESPN#9

No way he is NOT Top 10!

We all know Alphabet rankings are a joke. Let the poll get the right answers.

Your rating him way to high anyway. Top 5 is a joke right?

Are you Edison Miranda?

**Pantera2000** · 03-06-2008, 11:55 PM

Originally posted by Mike_Dee

Although Miranda is a "name", he is not a top ten fighter at 68 based on his resume at 68 thus far.

Why do you have to fight someone at that weight to make a difference? People go up all the time in weight and are immediately ranked on the top! You got to base the fact he was a HUGE middleweight and his power will if anything be much better at 168lbs. He beat everyone he faced except for the current MW champ (Pavlik). He even beat the **** out of Abraham.

No way in hell he is NOT a top 10 SMW!

Is Miranda in top 10 at SMW?