Why is pavlik vs taylor2 okay and mayweather vs oscar2 not??

[BrendanWoodside]

I like this rematch cause the first fight was exciting and i think either guy could win.. Definately more exciting than dlh and pbf

[Jim Jeffries]

B/c Taylor nearly beat him in the second round?? I think that sums it up..

Because taylor actually has a chance of winning, and dlh doesn't lol

Cosign.............

[Ironside]

this is what i answered on your other post

DLH was the champion, and the fight was close.
I dont think theres one person out there who would say taylor won his fight, but there are many opinions who say oscar won or they saw a draw. maybe mayweather does win it bigger then before, then he would have a clear unquestioned victory.( peoples scores besides the judges dont matter to me)

Haha, you're the same person I replied to in the other thread. I just replied there.

[moy22487]

Cosign.............

taylor was on the floor so the second round ment nothing,

oscar went into the fight with no prior fight and gave him a good fight, this time around it looks like mayweather is going to have the inactivity going into this fight

[El Dominicano]

To answer the thread! Its ok because Taylor put up a really good fight and PBF basically blew right threw Oscar! To a point where PBF could have done much more but chose to win by an easy U.D.

[DrewWoodside]

this fight cheats fans, dlh/pbf. Only diehard PBF fans want to see this. You'd think they were getting a percentage of the profits.

[moy22487]

To answer the thread! Its ok because Taylor put up a really good fight and PBF basically blew right threw Oscar! To a point where PBF could have done much more but chose to win by an easy U.D.

actually he won by split decision, and one of the judges was one round from a draw in the floyd fan. that judge gave floyd the 12th when the other 2 gave it to oscar, if he would of given it to oscar we would have had a draw.
Taylor did put up a good fight but there was a clear winner

[Ironside]

Just saw your post in the other thread Moy. Might as well reply here.

Oscar is having a tune-up, but will that really change much? When they fought it was PBF's first time at that weight division. I think he will be more comfortable this time around.

[Kball15]

he came close to beating him but at the end of the fight taylor was on the floor, and oscar was one point away from a draw.

Taylor was one big punch away from a 2nd round stoppage... big difference

Ive seen many rematch clause exercised and criticized on this site

Depends on the nature of the fight. Ndou-Malignaggi is BS. Malignaggi wooped Ndou and Ndou was never once in the fight.

Pavlik was nearly KOed, and came back to win. Taylor was also winning at the time of the stoppage.

This rematch makes all the sense in the world.

DLH-MAYWEATHER does not.

And its not all about entertainment. Casamayor-Cruz was a terrible fight, but everyone wants that rematch to happen because Cruz deserved the decision

[johnm is...]

There's absolutely no point in arguing this with you. Because anytime someone says something about Floyd clearly winning the fight, you just reply with "it was a SD... it doesn't matter what you think.. only what the judges say." etc. So why even make the thread, when the reality of it is... there's really nothing to discuss with you?