Calzaghe: Rank his top 5 opponents..

[champ007]

I've got one question? How is Robin Reid on the list, when Jeff Lacy already beat him? If jeff is crap as ya'll say. what does it say about Reid? Please remove this man from the list.

[blacksky]

Reid fought lacy when he was way past his best, Reid was a very dangerous fighter.

[Silencers]

I've got one question? How is Robin Reid on the list, when Jeff Lacy already beat him? If jeff is crap as ya'll say. what does it say about Reid? Please remove this man from the list.

Because Lacy fought Reid 6 years later.

[Jim Jeffries]

I've got one question? How is Robin Reid on the list, when Jeff Lacy already beat him? If jeff is crap as ya'll say. what does it say about Reid? Please remove this man from the list.

How is Muhammad Ali an ATG when Trevor Berbick beat him? Think about it.

[FUMIN 88]

1.Mikkel Kessler
2.Jeff Lacy
3.Chris Eubank
4.Robin Reid
5.Omar Shieka/Mario Veit/Charles Brewer/Richie Woodhall

jef lacy ahead of eubank get out of here

[blacksky]

i would even say that prime Reid beats Lacy

[TheGreatA]

The only losses Reid had on his record after the Calzaghe fight was a clear loss to Branco RIGHT after the close fight with Calzaghe. Then he had that 'loss' against Ottke.

He was still a highly ranked fighter so it counts for Lacy.

[blacksky]

Reids prime was the late nineties - 2000

the lacy fight was in 2005, Reid was way past it then

[HappyBoxingFan]

1. Eubank
2. Kessler
3. Reid
4. Lacy
5. Sheika

I'm really not sure who should be at 5 though.

You really think Eubank is better than Kessler? Are you serious? How? Wha? JUst, because Calzaghe wasn't favored when the fight took place does not make Eubank better than Kessler.

Look at this way. Miranda was favored when he fought Pavlik. Pavlik will be favored when he fights Abraham (probably), that does not make Miranda better than Abraham.

[blacksky]

Eubanks career achievements dwarf that of Kessler at the moment