If Floyd Beats Cotto Is He Better Than Sugar Ray Robinson?

[Rane-Ex54]

5 people have voted for Flyod, I would reallly like to see what these people have to say!! Ya'll need to speak up!!

[THE REED]

He wont be better than Ray Robinson, this is a ****** thread.

Floyd will make the Top 10 though if he beats him.

its a ******, necessary thread... i made it because these people seem to think he will be better than SRR

[RageX]

its a ******, necessary thread... i made it because these people seem to think he will be better than SRR

He will be better than Roy Jones though.

[Flab]

even if he did... cotto williams and cintron arent even hof fighters...

cottos got two good wins over questionable opponents...
pwill has one good win
and cintron is still yet to be a proven elite in my eyes

What a ****** thing to say! of course they aint HoFers, you don't get that honour until you've retired and then you still need to wait for 20 odd years.

[THE REED]

He will be better than Roy Jones though.

he could be... not currently though... and his fear of fighting anyone of serious threat may just hold him back from that

[Addition]

Dude, why don't you make polls public so we can see who voted for who?

[THE REED]

What a ****** thing to say! of course they aint HoFers, you don't get that honour until you've retired and then you still need to wait for 20 odd years.

first of all.. its 5 yrs retired... second of all... they wouldnt be voted after 20 yrs.. not yet anyway

[2501]

these 7 posters remind me of Lil Wayne fans that claim he is better than the god Rakim.

[butterfly1964]

You all can judge for yourselves.

Floyd Mayweather Jr.



Sugar Ray Robinson

[MikeBrew328]

Cotto doesn't really matter to me. If he beats Cotto, so what? Williams too, neither of them have the resume of De La Hoya. He should STILL fight both of them though.

I think he would fully fulfill his legacy by winning a world title at 160 lbs, middleweight. Sugar Ray Leonard did it, fought at 132 as an amateur and went up to 160, Ray Robinson started off his career fighting at 135, and went up to 160 to win a world title.