Better resume Floyd or Roy Jones JR

[Dynamite Kid]

all im saying is his inhability to make fights with Benn ,Eubank,Collins cost him an even greater legacy

at the end of the day the where better fights out there than Frazier & Hall it didnt have to be Collins ,Benn etc ,he wouldnt even fight Nunn who had lost how many fights by that time

im not saying he is a coward im just saying he took his foot of the gas & went into cruise control ,he was making **** loads of cash so & was recognised as the best fighter in the world why not fight the likes of Hall etc

it definetly hurt his legacy though IMO

[Brandish]

roy has defeated 16 former and current world champions in his career. and had over 22 title defenses

Jorge Castro (WBA middleweight champion)
Jorge Vaca (WBC welterweight champion)
Bernanrd Hopkins (IBF Middleweight Champion)
Thulani Malinga (WBC Super Middleweight Champion)
James Toney (IBF Super Middleweight Champion)
Vinnie Pazienza (WBA Light Middleweight Champion)
Eric Lucas (WBC Super Middleweight Champion)
Mike Mccallum (WBC Lightheavyweight Champion)
Virgil Hill (WBA Lightheavyweight Champion)
Lou De Valle (WBA Lightheavyweight Champion)
Otis Grant (WBO Middleweight Champion)
Reggie Johnson (IBF Lightheavyweight Champion)
Julio Gonzalez (WBO Lightheavyweight Champion)
Clinton Woods (IBF Lightheavy weight Champion)
John Ruiz (WBA Heavyweight Champion)
Antonio Tarver (WBC Lightheavyweight Champion)


Floyd defeated 13 former champions, with 12 title defenses. Also besting 4 potential Hofer's.

Genaro Hernandez (WBC Super Featherweight Champion)
Gregario Vargas (WBC Featherweight Champion)
Diego Corrales (IBF Super Featherweight Champion)
Carlos Hernandez (IBF Super Featherweight Champion)
Jesus Chavez (WBC Super Featherweight Champion)
Jose Luis Castillo (WBC Lightweight Champion)
De Marcus Corley (WBO Light Weltwerweight Champion)
Arturo Gatti (WBC Light Welterweight Champion)
Sharmba Mitchell (WBA Light Welterweight Champion)
Zab Judah (WBC/WBA/IBF Welterweight Champion)
Carlos Baldomir (WBC Welterweight Champion)
Oscar De La Hoya (WBC Light Middleweight Champion)
Ricky Hatton (IBF Jr. Welterweight Champion)

[Dynamite Kid]

roy has defeated 16 former and current world champions in his career. and had over 22 title defenses

Jorge Castro (WBA middleweight champion)
Jorge Vaca (WBC welterweight champion)
Bernanrd Hopkins (IBF Middleweight Champion)
Thulani Malinga (WBC Super Middleweight Champion)
James Toney (IBF Super Middleweight Champion)
Vinnie Pazienza (WBA Light Middleweight Champion)
Eric Lucas (WBC Super Middleweight Champion)
Mike Mccallum (WBC Lightheavyweight Champion)
Virgil Hill (WBA Lightheavyweight Champion)
Lou De Valle (WBA Lightheavyweight Champion)
Otis Grant (WBO Middleweight Champion)
Reggie Johnson (IBF Lightheavyweight Champion)
Julio Gonzalez (WBO Lightheavyweight Champion)
Clinton Woods (IBF Lightheavy weight Champion)
John Ruiz (WBA Heavyweight Champion)
Antonio Tarver (WBC Lightheavyweight Champion)


Floyd defeated 13 former champions, with 12 title defenses. Also besting 4 potential Hofer's.

Genaro Hernandez (WBC Super Featherweight Champion)
Gregario Vargas (WBC Featherweight Champion)
Diego Corrales (IBF Super Featherweight Champion)
Carlos Hernandez (IBF Super Featherweight Champion)
Jesus Chavez (WBC Super Featherweight Champion)
Jose Luis Castillo (WBC Lightweight Champion)
De Marcus Corley (WBO Light Weltwerweight Champion)
Arturo Gatti (WBC Light Welterweight Champion)
Sharmba Mitchell (WBA Light Welterweight Champion)
Zab Judah (WBC/WBA/IBF Welterweight Champion)
Carlos Baldomir (WBC Welterweight Champion)
Oscar De La Hoya (WBC Light Middleweight Champion)
Ricky Hatton (IBF Jr. Welterweight Champion)

potential HOF that means what Barry McGuigan ,Gerald McClellan are HOF not exactly great though are they

[DannYankee]

I Think roy has the better one and besides that to me roy was a joy to watch on hes prime way more then mayweather ever has or ever will be.

[KostyaTszyu44]

very close, i voted floyd but i can understand someone saying jones

[Dynamite Kid]

very close, i voted floyd but i can understand someone saying jones

i think its shortening up though after Roy's wins over Prince,Hanshaw

[El Dominicano]

I voted Floyd by a long way by mistake. I meant Floyd had the better resume SLIGHTLY

[Dynamite Kid]

I voted Floyd by a long way by mistake. I meant Floyd had the better resume SLIGHTLY

Ricky Frazier,Richard Hall>>> Castillo,Corrales

[MWMerlino]

They both had the ability to make their opponents look worthless but RJJ is still fighting and PBF retired...thats the biggest difference to me.

[C.Y.]

i voted for mayweather, but i do believe alot of his opponents were past their primes.

yeah i agree i cant make up my mind Floyds looks better on paper but a lot of the big names he fought were past thier best

McCallum = 39 years old champ at 154 and 160. fight at 175
Hill = just went through 12 rounds with DM
Paz = champ at 135 and 40. fight at 168

If anyone fought 'em past it, that's Roy

if anyone fought more guys past their prime when comparing the two ,its roy.. floyd has by far the better resume..

They both had the ability to make their opponents look worthless but RJJ is still fighting and PBF retired...thats the biggest difference to me.

roy has 5 losses and has been koed.. floyd hasnt.. thats the biggest difference to me