Better resume Floyd or Roy Jones JR

[Dynamite Kid]

RJJ & PBFM havent left anything to be desired in their careers. They have both beaten HOF fighters. Both medaled in the olympics & both have won world titles in several divisions. RJ was the 1st man in 100 years to win a legit middleweight & heavyweight title. Floyd was the 1st man to win titles in 5 divisions while staying undefeated. Some haters wont be happy until both of them are walknig around shaking & cant talk for themselves.

I am a Roy fan but how someone can say his career never left a bit to be desired is quite a strange comment to make

Benn ,Eubank ,Collins,Darius ,etc he clearly could have enhanced his legacy quite considerably with Victories of these oponents

he found time to beat Hall & Frazier ,WAKEY WAKEY Mate

[MightyMikeA]

Both have good resumes, but the deal breaker here is that Roy was always fun to watch as the talented unearthly fighter that he was who had KO power in both hands, whereas Floyd is not nearly as entertaining. Great fighter, but not as fun to watch.

[robjr]

I look at the poll results... what the hell are some of ya smoking?

theres a difference between beating an opponont..

and.

"just makin em look like NObody!"

[Haterfree]

I am a Roy fan but how someone can say his career never left a bit to be desired is quite a strange comment to make

Benn ,Eubank ,Collins,Darius ,etc he clearly could have enhanced his legacy quite considerably with Victories of these oponents

he found time to beat Hall & Frazier ,WAKEY WAKEY Mate

Thats your opinion. I respect it. You feel like Roy left something to be desired. I fell like he had an exceptional HOF career & Im not a big RJ fan.

[Haterfree]

The fact that Toney lost to Montell Griffin in his next fight did take something out of that victory though.

Technically Roy lost to Montel Griffin also. LOL

[TheGreatA]

Technically Roy lost to Montel Griffin also. LOL

Had Griffin retired after that DQ win he would be known as one of the greatest of all time.

[robjr]

[GTL]

man.. i miss ROY..

His resume was better than mayweathers.. he fought toney (p4p 1 at the time)
bhop, griffin, hill

[robjr]

I am a Roy fan but how someone can say his career never left a bit to be desired is quite a strange comment to make

Benn ,Eubank ,Collins,Darius ,etc he clearly could have enhanced his legacy quite considerably with Victories of these oponents

he found time to beat Hall & Frazier ,WAKEY WAKEY Mate

not roys fault that those guys didnt wana fight him.

[Dynamite Kid]

not roys fault that those guys didnt wana fight him.

i dont buy it these fights would have happened if Roy really wanted them to ,Roy was happy to be recogniseed as p4p & still make a **** load of money & fight his mandatorys

that is why he is great but not as great as he could have been ,Floyd will retire with the same credentials IMO