Floyd Mayweather Jr: "It Won't Go The Distance"

[BmoreBrawler]

Mayweather overall clearly has the stronger record, but simply looking at the DLH win vs the Tszyu win, Hatton comes out on top or at the very least equal to mayweather's win.

[DIOS DOMINICANO]

Oscar, not prime! He lost to Mosley, he should've lost to Sturm who is a very average fighter. He lost to Bernard and he got hit a bit by a very shot fighter in Vargas. He fought Mayweather at 154 cause he knew his speed didn't used to be what it used to be when he was PRIME. That's a very bad record and when you couple that with inactivity, that's definately not PRIME in my book.
I just proved OTHERWISE.

You lost two arguments in one thread in a matter of two pages with respect to fighters being ELITE and PRIME, a concept that should be credited to you since you were the fist one to use these terms on the forum here.

1) I disagree.
2) You said "in my book"

Two arguments that mean you haven't "proved" anything.

[K-Nan]

Fine, neither fighters were prime, but they were both still eliete's who could beat a majority of people in their respective divisons.

Argument settled?

This shoulda been said a while ago. You people need to find a balance here. Meaning that **** isn't black and white-- If Hatton does well, it doesn't mean Floyd did worse. And vice-versa.

[pesticid]

Fine, neither fighters were prime, but they were both still eliete's who could beat a majority of people in their respective divisons.

Argument settled?

The argument was settled when DD finally admitted that Kostya was both PRIME and ELITE when he fought Ricky. However, he still thinks that Oscar was prime when he fought PBF when he was clearly shown otherwise.

[DIOS DOMINICANO]

Mayweather overall clearly has the stronger record, but simply looking at the DLH win vs the Tszyu win, Hatton comes out on top or at the very least equal to mayweather's win.

Really? In what way was Tszyu superior to Oscar?

If you asked the top 50 Jww's/ww's who would be a tougher fight for them:

36 yr old Tszyu at 140 or 34 yr old Oscar at 154

What do you think they would tell you?

[DIOS DOMINICANO]

The argument was settled when DD finally admitted that Kostya was both PRIME and ELITE when he fought Ricky. However, he still thinks that Oscar was prime when he fought PBF when he was clearly shown otherwise.

Nope.

They were BOTH prime and elite... or NEITHER was prime and elite.

[pesticid]

1) I disagree.
2) You said "in my book"

Two arguments that mean you haven't "proved" anything.

Well, you already agreed with me since you said Kostya was PRIME and ElITE when he fought Ricky. So clearly an easy win for me there since we have it black on white. Now you're trying to weasel your way out and make DLH a PRIME fighter when he fought PBF.

Hence, the moniker, the Dominican Weasel. You got beat bad today.

[pesticid]

Nope.

They were BOTH prime and elite... or NEITHER was prime and elite.

Oh, now it's OR or OR. What are you a tweener, changing your mind every other minute.

[BmoreBrawler]

Really? In what way was Tszyu superior to Oscar?

If you asked the top 50 Jww's/ww's who would be a tougher fight for them:

36 yr old Tszyu at 140 or 34 yr old Oscar at 154

What do you think they would tell you?

I'd say a skilled Tsyzu at Hatton's normal weight, in which Hatton obliterated him, is better than a win over a fighter who almost beat mayweather in spite of his amateurish stamina collapse in the late rounds.

[Mozza]

Would YOU rather knock out Mayorga in six rounds or have three surgeries?

That would be a valid question if Hatton was Tszyu's first opponent since the surgery but he wasn't.