Who's resume is better? Hatton or Cotto?

[satori555]

tsuyu was shot to **** when hatton fought him and hatton barely beat him
now juan urango thats a great great fighter and i give lots of cred for that brilliant win.

[eric maldonado]

Yeh because tszyu at the time was better than when mosley fought cotto

no he wasn't he beat a sharmba that wasn't the same due to the knee injury he sustained during his first fight wth tszyu and shane just came off a win against collazo and everyone seem to think shane look so good in the fight with collazo.and tszyu was never and never will be better than shane mosley

[Antwuan Maxx]

beating tszyu is better than beating mosley?

Yeh because tszyu at the time was better than when mosley fought cotto

Agreed. Tszyu may have been inactive, but he damn sure didn't look close to being shot against Mitchell. Matter of fact, I predicted Tszyu would destory Hatton. Stil, I'm not a big fan of how Hatton beat him. But the fact of matter is, Tszyu was P4P top ten when Hatton fought him. Mosley was not.

[PBDS]

Cotto by a long shot.
Kostya Tszyu is such an overrated fighter in these forums its a shame. The guy isnt even a boxer to me he fights once every 3 yrs. And quit on his stool. Plus he loss to D rated fighters as well.
Plus we all know that JL Castillo was shot when he faced Hatton

...****** **** like this will get you red every single time newb.

[eric maldonado]

tszyu dominated a bumb ass division. wow!

[stark]

Much as i want hatton to win at weekend i cant see past Cotto having the better resume just look at the facts:

Kostya Tszyu - a great win u cant say he was past it hed just spanked zab but he had been inactive even so great win.
Jose Luis Castillo - a solid win against a fading fighter who was lucky to win his last fight prior to hatton
Vince Phillips - shop won and only won 4 fights after hatton who batterd him
Luis Collazo - a solid win]
Juan Urango - ok win over an akward opponent but what else will urango do on the wold scene?

Shane Mosley - top draw win, mosley thew everything but the kitchen sink at cotto and still got beat make no mistake shane would have beaten most fighters bar cotto that night.
Zab Judah - zab only looses to the best a good win
Carlos Quintana - ok win
Paul Malignaggi - good win over a good fighter
Ricardo Torres - good win win Torres has beaten some decent fighters

much as like hatton i think some of his best wins are against fading fighters, cotton has taken on youg hungry fighters and veterans and batterd everyone

[Warrior Rage]

Easy decision for me. Cotto.

[1pretty boy1]

Vote now please.

Hatton's top 5 wins:

Kostya Tszyu
Jose Luis Castillo
Vince Phillips
Luis Collazo
Juan Urango

Cotto's top 5 wins:

Shane Mosley
Zab Judah
Carlos Quintana
Paul Malignaggi
Ricardo Torres

cotto's resume better one hall of famer(mosley)one former undisputed champion(judah) and two current champions

[AntonTheMeh]

cotto's resume better one hall of famer(mosley)one former undisputed champion(judah) and two current champions

not to mention all the undefeated fighters he's beaten

[AntonTheMeh]

the kostya and mosley wins are even,anybody picking one win over the other is just a dumb fan.