Who's resume is better? Hatton or Cotto?

[mrpain81]

People that say Cotto are crazy, Hatton on the fact he was the true champion at 140. Cotto has beaten good fighter but hasnt been the real champ at 140 or 147.

[AntonTheMeh]

People that say Cotto are crazy, Hatton on the fact he was the true champion at 140. Cotto has beaten good fighter but hasnt been the real champ at 140 or 147.

i wonder why?hum?

[Parody]

Truth hurts, don't it? I've already seen you call Hatton a bum, now you're saying his resume is better than Cottos?

Can you quote him on that?

Because from all I've seen from his posts, he has given Hatton credit and talked about him being a great fighter. He also said that Hatton has a chance of beating Mayweather. We arent talking out of our ass now are we?

[crillz]

Vote now please.

Hatton's top 5 wins:

Kostya Tszyu
Jose Luis Castillo
Vince Phillips
Luis Collazo
Juan Urango

Cotto's top 5 wins:

Shane Mosley
Zab Judah
Carlos Quintana
Paul Malignaggi
Ricardo Torres

Cotto for sure, I don't even see how this can be close, in 31 fights for over half of them Cotto fought either past or present world champions, known names too not some unrecognizable names who if they are good their names don't stick up for them.. in his 10th fight he fought Justin Jukko and if I'm not mistaken he KO'ed him, regardless Cotto been brought up against championship level fighters and this has been from his 10th fight and up, he avenged his Ametuer losses and did them both with KO's, he beat top quality guys for the most part of his career so it baffles me to think anyone would pick Ricky over Miguel, Shane Mosley alone is better than all 5 of those guys you named for Hatton, maybe Kostya is good but c'mon mad Ricky held his way on to a win, Kostya is a class act so he ain't going to say "**** **** **** **** **** **** he grabbed me" he gonna say he got no problems, I actually think Cotto would have TKO'ed Tszyu and I don't say that about much people.. 100

[eric maldonado]

[QUOTE=Parody;2861730]Vote now please.

Hatton's top 5 wins:

Kostya Tszyu
Jose Luis Castillo washed up. coming up from 135
Vince Phillips wasn't **** but beat tszyu
Luis Collazo close fight but i gave it to collazo
Juan Urango aint **** he got dropped by somebody on friday noght fights

Cotto's top 5 wins:

Shane Mosley
Zab Judah just lost to mayweather and baldomir
Carlos Quintana was undefeated at the time
Paul Malignaggi was undeafeted at the time and is now a champ at 140
Ricardo Torres was undefeated at the time and is now a champ at 140

i think cotto's is better

[Seminole]

Cotto's in another league from Ricky, not even close.

[FloydNO1KO]

hatton of course and those who say otherwise are gay

[Antwuan Maxx]

Hatton has the biggest win on either record. That being against Kostya Tszyu. However, the way he beat him (clinching, fouling and questionable treatment from a biased ref) takes a little luster away from the victory. Castillo was NOT a top/P4P fighter at the time Hatton fought him, regardless of what some are saying. Top fighters don't win split decisions, arguably even losing, to fighters nearly KO'd by Emanuel Augustus. I think the Ngoudjo and Reyes fights clearly showed the wars with Corrales had taken their toll on Castillo. Which is why I predicted Hatton would stop him. In my opinion, Cotto clearly has the better resume. More than a few fighters on his record, went on to hold world titles, and there's a few names on there who I would favor over Hatton.

[eric maldonado]

Hatton has the biggest win on either record. That being against Kostya Tszyu. However, the way he beat him (clinching, fouling and questionable treatment from a biased ref) takes a little luster away from the victory. Castillo was NOT a top/P4P fighter at the time Hatton fought him, regardless of what some are saying. Top fighters don't win split decisions, arguably even losing, to fighters nearly KO'd by Emanuel Augustus. I think the Ngoudjo and Reyes fights clearly showed the wars with Corrales had taken their toll on Castillo. Which is why I predicted Hatton would stop him. In my opinion, Cotto clearly has the better resume. More than a few fighters on his record, went on to hold world titles, and there's a few names on there who I would favor over Hatton.

beating tszyu is better than beating mosley?

[FloydNO1KO]

beating tszyu is better than beating mosley?

Yeh because tszyu at the time was better than when mosley fought cotto