Who's resume is better? Hatton or Cotto?

[WLAD OWNS]

I have to give the edge to Hatton, his biggest wins over Tszyu and Castillo are better than Cotto's two biggest wins over Mosley and Judah. You could also argue that the past his prime Mosley beat Cotto.

[Dynamite Kid]

Vote now please.

Hatton's top 5 wins:

Kostya Tszyu
Jose Luis Castillo
Vince Phillips
Luis Collazo
Juan Urango

Cotto's top 5 wins:

Shane Mosley
Zab Judah
Carlos Quintana
Paul Malignaggi
Ricardo Torres

hard to say but i go for Cotto , Mosley is a big scalp Malignaggi & Torres are current champions

Phillips ,Castillo past their prime ,Collazo good fighter gave Ricky nuff trouble ,Urango who

Tszyu is a great name to have on your record but i would sonner have Mosley's name on my record

[AntonTheMeh]

Vote now please.

Hatton's top 5 wins:

Kostya Tszyu even as a win with mosley
Jose Luis Castillo shot to hell,too many wars
Vince Phillips ehhh
Luis Collazo you could argue he lost
Juan Urango overrated

Cotto's top 5 wins:

Shane Mosley even with a win with kostya
Zab Judah a basketcase with a lot of skill
Carlos Quintana undefeated
Paul Malignaggi undefeated
Ricardo Torres undefeated

the more i think of it,cotto,slightly.

[bishop2006]

Is it even close? Cotto.

The only TOP names on Hattons resume are Tszyu & Castillo,who where both kinda shot,especially Castillo,plus he was coming up from lightweight,u can say Juan Urango and Collazo aswell but there not top class

Cotto has got Shane Mosley,Zab Judah,Paul Malignaggi (Champ) & Quintana ( Who in my mind is better then both Urango and Collazo )

Cotto has also fought Ricardo Torres (champ) and DeMarcus Corley

If Hatton beats Floyd,his resume will be better,but as of now,its Cottos

[Parody]

I think Both Tsyzu and Castillo were in the P4P List when Hatton fought them, Judah was coming off 2 losses and Mosley was'nt ranked in the P4P List either.

[RAESAAD]

I have to give the edge to Hatton, his biggest wins over Tszyu and Castillo are better than Cotto's two biggest wins over Mosley and Judah. You could also argue that the past his prime Mosley beat Cotto.

Please tell me you're kidding?

[Parody]

Is it even close? Cotto.

The only TOP names on Hattons resume are Tszyu & Castillo,who where both kinda shot,especially Castillo,plus he was coming up from lightweight,u can say Juan Urango and Collazo aswell but there not top class

Cotto has got Shane Mosley,Zab Judah,Paul Malignaggi & Quintana ( Who in my mind is better then both Urango and Collazo )

Cotto has also fought Ricardo Torres and DeMarcus Corley

If Hatton beats Floyd,his resume will be better,but as of now,its Cottos

What about Castillo?

[Dynamite Kid]

I think Both Tsyzu and Castillo were in the P4P List when Hatton fought them, Judah was coming off 2 losses and Mosley was'nt ranked in the P4P List either.

yeah doesnt that just illustrate what the p4p list means

[AntonTheMeh]

I think Both Tsyzu and Castillo were in the P4P List when Hatton fought them, Judah was coming off 2 losses and Mosley was'nt ranked in the P4P List either.

kostya yes,castillo,hell no................

[Mozza]

I have to give it to Hatton because his two biggest wins have been two very impressive stoppages.