Who faced better comp at WW? Floyd or Cotto?

[deevel79]

Floyd: Mitchell/Judah/Baldomir

Cotto: Quintana/Judah/Mosley

[eazy_mas]

about the same but Cotto has the edge

[cupcrazy01]

It's not close.

Quintana > Mitchell

Mosley >>> Baldy

Advantage Cotto.

[2501]

Cotto..........

[AntonTheMeh]

Floyd: Mitchell/Judah/Baldomir

Cotto: Quintana/Judah/Mosley

i think you just opened up a can of worms that's gonna catch you alot of fish.
quintana is better mitchell
mosley is better than baldo
you could argue judah was a better judah vs mosley
but i don't believe that
if anything the rest did judah some good.

[Mozza]

Cotto by some distance.

[cupcrazy01]

Not to mention I think the Judah in the Cotto fight was a more confident Judah, which makes him more dangerous.

In the Mayweather fight, Judah was coming off the embarrassing loss and surely had his confidence shaken (not an uncommon occurence for the mercurial welterweight), and he didn't hold the speed/quickness advantage (or at least as much of one) over Floyd like he did over Cotto by a mile.

[Fox McCloud]

Not to mention I think the Judah in the Cotto fight was a more confident Judah, which makes him more dangerous.

In the Mayweather fight, Judah was coming off the embarrassing loss and surely had his confidence shaken (not an uncommon occurence for the mercurial welterweight), and he didn't hold the speed/quickness advantage (or at least as much of one) over Floyd like he did over Cotto by a mile.

He had just come off two embarrasing losses before the Cotto fight. I think Zab vs. Floyd was better than Zab vs. Cotto... doesn't matter overall though, Cotto has faced better competition at 147. If you add De La Hoya for Mayweather at 147 (since he fought weighing 148), then it becomes awfully close, with advantage to Mayweather, considering it was a welterweight vs. a junior middleweight.

Straight up 147 vs. 147 goes to Cotto.

[sonofisis]

* Baldomir was the undisputed WW champ and would smash Quintana's face in who is nothing more than a prospect and hasn't fought anyone besides Cotto.

* Mosley's better than Mitchell

* The Judah that fought Mayweather was yards ahead of the shot, broken fighter coming off a year lay off and a loss in the Judah who fought Cotto.


Not to mention that Floyd beat the man who beat the man, which makes him the Champ. Cotto beat Floyd's leftovers and a game, but past it former champ who hasn't owned a belt at welter weight in years.

Mayweather has fought the better fighters overall at Welter, since we must include Hatton now as well, not to mention better comp through out his entire career.

[AntonTheMeh]

* Baldomir was the undisputed WW champ and would smash Quintana's face in who is nothing more than a prospect and hasn't fought anyone besides Cotto.

* Mosley's better than Mitchell

* The Judah that fought Mayweather was yards ahead of the shot, broken fighter coming off a year lay off and a loss in the Judah who fought Cotto.


Not to mention that Floyd beat the man who beat the man, which makes him the Champ. Cotto beat Floyd's leftovers and a game, but past it former champ who hasn't owned a belt at welter weight in years.

always manage to do it.
wow.