Who faced better comp at WW? Floyd or Cotto?

[sonofisis]

This guy must have some type of congenital disorder to where he can only communicate with the outside world by use of smileys.

[cupcrazy01]

And I thought Floyd fans considered Hatton no threat and unworthy of a fight...and now he's better than anyone Cotto has faced?

Oh well, the great thing about the way boxing is going is that big fights are getting made. Cotto-PBF is a huge fight, I think. I just hope PBF and Arum can kiss and make up enough to make it happen.

[deevel79]

Bull crap! A faded 36 year old Shane is never more dangerous than a prime Castillo, Corrales, Hernandez, or Hatton (at Welter)..

Listen, your biasness is getting in the way of you thinking clearly. There is no way on this earth that u can say that Floyd has faced anybody at WW that is more of a threat than Mosley. NOBODY!

[AntonTheMeh]

This guy must have some type of congenital disorder to where he can only communicate with the outside world by use of smileys.

once again

[sonofisis]

Listen, your biasness is getting in the way of you thinking clearly. There is no way on this earth that u can say that Floyd has faced anybody at WW that is more of a threat than Mosley. NOBODY!

Please do not move the goal post as it is very disingenuous and makes you seem dishonest.

Quote: And Shane is better than ANYBODY Floyd has faced in his entire career at any weight. - deevel79

^I mention a prime Castillo, Corrales, and Genero, and you go off on a tangent about Welter weights again, after being called out for that absurd statement, which still applies even at Welter since Hatton again, is more dangerous than a 36 year old, past his prime Shane Mosley..

And I thought Floyd fans considered Hatton no threat and unworthy of a fight..

Foolish straw man.. Generalizing all floyd mayweather fans with no point of reference and indirectly applying it to me only makes you look desperately foolish.

[Burning Desire]

Im Mayweather fan but Cotto has the slight edge.

[deevel79]

Please do not move the goal post as it is very disingenuous and makes you seem dishonest.

Quote: And Shane is better than ANYBODY Floyd has faced in his entire career at any weight. - deevel79

^I mention a prime Castillo, Corrales, and Genero, and you go off on a tangent about Welter weights again, after being called out for that absurd statement, which still applies even at Welter since Hatton again, is more dangerous than a 36 year old, past his prime Shane Mosley..



Foolish straw man.. Generalizing all floyd mayweather fans with no point of reference and indirectly applying it to me only makes you look desperately foolish.

Ok, we both veered off a bit. Lets get back to the original question which was "who faced better comp at 147" There is nobody that Floyd faced at 147 that was more of a threat than Shane! Stop bringing up Hatton, because he hasnt even faced Hatton yet. Funny how u have been dismissing Hatton as easy work for Floyd, but all of a sudden for the purpose of this thread, he is a BIG threat in the WW division. LOL.

[deevel79]

Im Mayweather fan but Cotto has the slight edge.

Look Isis. Even your fellow Floyd fans disagree with you.

[sonofisis]

Ok, we both veered off a bit. Lets get back to the original question which was "who faced better comp at 147" There is nobody that Floyd faced at 147 that was more of a threat than Shane!

Including Hatton,. who Floyd is inevitably stepping in against, of course you're wrong.

Stop bringing up Hatton, because he hasnt even faced Hatton yet.

It makes no sense to make such a thread like this only 3 days after Cotto fights a big name, with a Mayweather fight with Hatton being within weeks, yet trying to compare who's fighting better comp at WW without mentioning Hatton. It is set up to be knocked over and I'm not falling for that. Unless Floyd breaks his leg tomorrow, I'm counting Hatton, since I'm realistic and it realistically equals Floyd taking on tough competition.

Funny how u have been dismissing Hatton as easy work for Floyd

Cotto and Mosley would be easy work for Floyd, that doesn't mean they aren't good fighters..

[Welter_Skelter]

Floyd: Mitchell/Judah/Baldomir

Cotto: Quintana/Judah/Mosley

I am going to have to go with Cotto