Question for DIOS and his FAN CLUB

[Azteca]

Diego Corrales was the only P4P rated fighter Floyd ever faced who was rated at that time. Even thoguht Castillo, Judah, Corley and De La Hoya were considered p4p at some point in their career they were not at the time Floyd fought them.

So Floyd's really quite extraordinary resume has only one p4p guy better than Calzaghe, who remains undefeated 22-0 in title fights. Moving up the weights is only one way of establishing yourself, and it's much easier to move up five weightclassed when you make your start at Jr Featherweight than it is if you make your start at Super Middle.

That has got to be the most meaningless debate i have read on the board. P4p is all OPINION based...not factual.

[!! Mr. Soprano]

You can't compare the two. Cals is a legitimate 168 pounder. Floyd could still make 135 if he wanted to. I don't think Kessler outweighed Cal by 20 pounds last night.

154 down to 135? you're pushing it!

[ElGranLuchador]

154 down to 135? you're pushing it!

agree mayweather cant make 135 anymore y u think he wants to fight at 147 against hatton cuz thats his best weight

[squealpiggy]

That has got to be the most meaningless debate i have read on the board. P4p is all OPINION based...not factual.

It is but all rankings are opinion based unless the guys have actually fought each other. In fact the types of rankings that are not opinion based are the ones that recieve the most criticism, eg the Boxrec rankings.

At least a p4p rating has a good chance of being relatively unbiased, because you don't really have an incentive by being ranked higher.

154 down to 135? you're pushing it!

148 down to 135. It's only 13 lbs.

[demirturk]

You can't compare the two. Cals is a legitimate 168 pounder. Floyd could still make 135 if he wanted to. I don't think Kessler outweighed Cal by 20 pounds last night.

by that logic

im pretty sure calzaghe could have made 160 , maybe 154 too ? lol j/jk

[Vladimir303]

I see you're as constipated as Floyd in your avatar

Why don't you name one Floyd fought at 140 and up and traded like a man.

Floyd fought like a man vs Gatti at 140. He fough like a man vs Mitchell coming forward and knocked him out via bodyshot.

Floyd fought like a man against Zab Judah coming forward.


Is that enough????????

[ElGranLuchador]

Floyd fought like a man vs Gatti at 140. He fough like a man vs Mitchell coming forward and knocked him out via bodyshot.

Floyd fought like a man against Zab Judah coming forward.


Is that enough????????

gatti was shot before the fight with floyd
judah is known to have the worst chin in boxing
and zab is an embarrasment he was just coming off a lost to baldomir in the biggest upset of the year
its easy to come forward when ur oponents just suffered humilliating loses

[!! Mr. Soprano]

Floyd fought like a man vs Gatti at 140. He fough like a man vs Mitchell coming forward and knocked him out via bodyshot.

Floyd fought like a man against Zab Judah coming forward.


Is that enough????????

And are any of those overrated underachievers are on the same level as Kessler?

[SkillspayBills]

154 down to 135? you're pushing it!

YOU are pushing it, did Floyd weight 154 for that fight? Did Floyd even weigh 150 for his last fight?

[SkillspayBills]

agree mayweather cant make 135 anymore y u think he wants to fight at 147 against hatton cuz thats his best weight

He is at 147 because THAT IS WHERE ALL THE MONEY IS AT.