Who's Best 140lb Fighter in History

[joepal]

well look for you for youself:

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/view.php?pg=pound

http://www.thering-online.com/ringpages/ratings2.html

and even go to to other espn or boxing website you will see the same. If those two website is not convicnging and the espn I dont know what to say more to you,

Who are the editors of these forums? A-M-E-R-I-C-A-N-S.

[joepal]

trust me, we all know that most the Pinoy writers dont have Floyd p4p #1


anyways, Chavez by far has the best record at 140lbs. I think Whitaker would have beaten all the rest of them, but he had a very very short reign at 140. and that certainly matters.

Kostya is up definitely up there along with Pryor. I wouldnt say the rest have a huge claim.

Most ASIAN fighters dont have Floyd in their p4p.

[Fox McCloud]

Most ASIAN fighters dont have Floyd in their p4p.

Thanks for destroying their credibility so we didn't have to.

Not even in the top 10? Wow, very credible source you have there.

[joepal]

Thanks for destroying their credibility so we didn't have to.

Not even in the top 10? Wow, very credible source you have there.

Well, Asians have a thing for exciting fighters, can't blame them.

They live for interesting times, as the saying goes.

[Fox McCloud]

Well, Asians have a thing for exciting fighters, can't blame them.

They live for interesting times, as the saying goes.

I can blame them for factoring their excitement bias into a "supposive" objective P4P list.

[joepal]

I can blame them for factoring their excitement bias into a "supposive" objective P4P list.

How is excitment subjective?

Surely you get excited with Jordan and a naked Ms. Universe, right?

[Fox McCloud]

How is excitment subjective?

Surely you get excited with Jordan and a naked Ms. Universe, right?

It's subjective when you are trying to establish who is the best fighter pound for pound, not the most exciting pound for pound.

[joepal]

It's subjective when you are trying to establish who is the best fighter pound for pound, not the most exciting pound for pound.

I said they factored in excitement, along with resume, skills, offensive output, etc.

And who said the most exciting fighter can't be the best fighter?

[Fox McCloud]

I said they factored in excitement, along with resume, skills, offensive output, etc.

And who said the most exciting fighter can't be the best fighter?

No one... but you said that they don't have Mayweather in their P4P lists, because they like excitement.

Seems to be disqualifying Mayweather because he is not exciting, which is completely subjective in a P4P best fighter rating.

[joepal]

No one... but you said that they don't have Mayweather in their P4P lists, because they like excitement.

Seems to be disqualifying Mayweather because he is not exciting, which is completely subjective in a P4P best fighter rating.

Are you ******ed? What part of what I posted didn't you understand? Lotsa people dont have Calderon in their p4p lists. Does that mean he aint p4p? IMO Calderon beats Floyd any day, all day.