Greatest Middleweight Ever

[Sin City]

My favorite middleweight is marvin hagler, however judging by record I would have to say Monzon. Now I have never seen a Monzon fight so I am gonna judge it by record instead of favoritism and say Monzon, damn is his record impressive!..

[Lubutheimmortal]

As far as one fight and one fight only I'd say.
Hagler > Robinson
Monzon > Robinson
Hagler .....(damn hard call) ....(ehhhh) > Monzon (I......flipped a coin lol)

BUT

As someone said Robinson shined in rematches. I favor Robinson winning the next 2 fights against Monzon, and Hagler. I mean he was so old and over the hill fighting future hall of famers in prime shape! So the best Robinson at MW has a good chance in 3 fights!

So I guess it depends on how you look at the question

1F = Hagler
3F = Robinson

Thats my opinion anyway. Also I would ****ing love to see Monzon vs Halger. WHAT A FIGHT!

[C.Y.]

no question
marvin hagler

[duffgun]

I voted for Stanley Ketchel as no one else did, he was a very powerfull puncher and had a good record. he has 3 wins over Billy Papke (i have there fourth fight on dvd) he beat Jack O'Brien the light heavy champ and a unoffical draw with Sam Langford. he was the first middleweight to regain the title. and was only 24 when he was shot.

[Smashing]

surely its Monzon or Grebb

[Panamaniac]

I think most of us are going to say R.Robinson!

Boy, are you wrong... So was I, for that matter...

[elgaringo]

Harry Greb for sure. I cant believe he has so little votes. That guy could fight all night.

[Lubutheimmortal]

Boy, are you wrong... So was I, for that matter...

Lol yea same here bud, but its good to see some people have some sense and not just saying Robinson to "fit it". I mean I rly dont know cause Hagler, SRR, and Monzon are easily ATG and all deserve a nod at the GOAT of MW. Hell I flipped a coin w/ Halger Monzon... .

[Thread Stealer]

why does hagler have almost 4 times as many votes as monzon?

[Sweet Pete]

LOL at the voting.