Does Jermain Taylor deserve to be off the P4P list?

[Super_Lightweight]

There is absolutely no justification for taking Jermain off and still having Floyd on there.

None whatsoever.

[niceguy45]

right now i thind he does, he has not ducked anyone is undefeated has a clean resume, and does not bull-**** like mayweather and gets paid less and gives a great effort to make it a fight, in eyes right up to this point yes he does need to be up there somewhere

[-EX-]

Hell no. Jermain definently belongs up there.

[TheEvilSaint]

his fights with hopkins and winky are history, forgotten already. his last two fights have been such stinkers against smaller fighters, that he lost a lot of credit for the fights he had before.

honestly, i think taylor is getting too much credit for his credentials. the 1st fight with hopkins was a joke. the 2nd one, taylor didnt really improve. he didnt beat winky, period. so i dont see how he should really get credit for a draw.

pavlik's inevitable victory over taylor will show that taylor was never anything more than a product who got pushed into the spotlight.