Is Hatton One of the Top 30 Fighters of the Last Decade?

[Technical_Skill]

You named your 30 fighters to Miksterious, so I'd appreciate you naming their achievements ( since 1997 ) and why they are better than Hatton ( Again, since 1997 ) please ?

Again, Stop ending every rant of yours with some random abstract phrase and then ending it in a derisive "LOL" - It's annoying and just makes you look like a fool.

Okay here's where reading the whole thread instead of entering late is benefical.

I know your Woman tells you its okay to Come Late, but it doesnt apply in this instance.

The list for Miksterious was 30 FIGHTERS BETTER THAN HATTON, not based on achivements, but skills, aka, who is the better fighter.

20 of those fighters are multi weight world champs anyways so there goes your above arguement.

Ready? 1,2,3...........


LOL.

[.Mik.]

The list for Miksterious was 30 FIGHTERS BETTER THAN HATTON, not based on achivements, but skills, aka, who is the better fighter.

But nobody asked for that list. I said that I considered Hatton to be a top 20-30 fighter over the past 10 years. Your list was supposed to be refuting that not by naming 30 fighters who you considered to be better fighters, but by naming 30 who had been better over the past 10 years. I cant see how its possible to do that without taking into account achievements. Tyson fought in the past years and was undoubtedly a better fighter than Hatton, but no way was he a 'better fighter of the past 10 years', cos since 1997 Tyson has been effectively ****.

[Technical_Skill]

But nobody asked for that list. I said that I considered Hatton to be a top 20-30 fighter over the past 10 years. Your list was supposed to be refuting that not by naming 30 fighters who you considered to be better fighters, but by naming 30 who had been better over the past 10 years. I cant see how its possible to do that without taking into account achievements. Tyson fought in the past years and was undoubtedly a better fighter than Hatton, but no way was he a 'better fighter of the past 10 years', cos since 1997 Tyson has been effectively ****.

Easy.

If i can name 30 fighters in the last 10 years that are better fighters than Hatton.

So can others

Aka, he probably is NOT one of the best 20-30 fighters in the last 10 years.

I never mentioned Tyson.

Its relevant.

Notice how the poll has closed in though, as more people are voting the gap has closed down.

Parody did a list of 30 based on achivements anyways, so if you dodge my bullet, you'll walk straight into his.

[Technical_Skill]

After re-reading your post, Mik it seems you have been confused

1) My list contains greats from the last 10 years

2) 20 of them are multi Weight world champs

So i have taken Achivements into context

Take any one of my 30 and lets match them up against hatton achievements wise, Eastenders is done now, i could do with the enertainment.

[.Mik.]

But both of your lists are just as arguable as the argument that Hatton is above many of the people on the lists.

You keep seeming to refer to your list as though its a nailed on fact that is not open for dispute. Some people have already disputed it. I dont have time at the moment to post a detailed analysis of which I agree with and which I disagree with and the reasons for it all. I've got a very busy week up ahead, remind me on Friday and we can have a lengthy discussion about it then.

[Technical_Skill]

But both of your lists are just as arguable as the argument that Hatton is above many of the people on the lists.

You keep seeming to refer to your list as though its a nailed on fact that is not open for dispute. Some people have already disputed it. I dont have time at the moment to post a detailed analysis of which I agree with and which I disagree with and the reasons for it all. I've got a very busy week up ahead, remind me on Friday and we can have a lengthy discussion about it then.

haha, okay, friday if im still around by then.

Im busy too, work, Champions League final on next wednesday night (go Milan!), mind you, no F1 this weekend. pah!

[deliveryman]

Let's see...

In no particular order (off the top of my head, probably going to forget a few obvious ones):

Lennox Lewis
Floyd Mayweather
Naseem Hamed
Erik Morales
Marco Antonio Barrera
Oscar De La Hoya
Shane Mosley
Roy Jones Jr.
Manny Pacquiao
James Toney
Wlad Klitschko
Vitali Klitschko
Bernard Hopkins
Felix Trinidad
Joe Calzaghe
Chris Eubank
Nigel Benn
Julio Cesar Chavez
Kostya Tsyzu
Pernell Whitaker
Winky Wright
Fernando Vargas
Diego Corrales
Evander Holyfield
Virgil Hill
Jose Luis Castillo
Stevie Johnston
Joel Casamayor
Genero Hernandez
Zab Judah
Ricky Hatton

Maybe top 30, but near the tail end of it. Top 35 for sure. He needs another big win. Cause right now all he's riding on is the Kostya win.

At least someone like Vargas has wins over Winky and Quartey

[Steelhammer86]

And even though i didnt go and give you a one star rating, cos im not a ***** like you, you still have a two star rating LMAO, i admit, i was tempted to see if i could take you down to one star, keep being a *****, and you may find out.

Yes, I have only two stars, because six Hatton Haters (including you and $iN) gave me a one star rating. If other Hatton Haters want to do the same, they are free to do so. But it won't stop me from defending him.

If you were an intelligent person, you'd understand that hating someone because of his nationality is both ****** and ethically wrong. If Hatton was of Caribbean heritage like yourself, you wouldn't be so hard on him, would you?

[SacTown1]

Hatton is in his prime, undefeated, and is a fun, energetic, exciting prizefighter....who is barely top-10 at this moment, let alone top-100 of the past 30 years....

Floyd, Margarito, and PW would all be betting favorites at this moment over the Hitman

[Technical_Skill]

Yes, I have only two stars, because six Hatton Haters (including you and $iN) gave me a one star rating. If other Hatton Haters want to do the same, they are free to do so. But it won't stop me from defending him.

If you were an intelligent person, you'd understand that hating someone because of his nationality is both ****** and ethically wrong. If Hatton was of Caribbean heritage like yourself, you wouldn't be so hard on him, would you?

Not interested, im done with you on this forum, you did what you did, i cant talk to people who give people one star cos they dont agree with someone elses opinion.

What you did to me, i did back to you,

And besides people have been very nice to me today, i have recived more Good Karma than usual today which is quite a bit, and some nice poster even donated me some points, which was a suprise,

So its over for me,
dont ever talk about my Heritadge again either.