Where Do You Rank Mayweather's All-Time?

[The Raging Bull]

Top 20.

A few more big fights and he'll crack the top 10.

[Easy-E]

Top 15 probably.
A convincing win over mosley may eek him into the top 10.

[Undocumented]

Only if he fights ands beats: Mosley, Cotto, Berto, clottey etc. You can't build a legacy on whoopin BS fighters and collecting belts. Floyd is skilled...but his style is boring...nervous.

[RayLeonard82]

Top 25. He still has more to prove. Id like to see him stay at 147 and clean out the division then retire. Then id consider him in the top 10 or top 15.

He has to beat Shane Mosley, and clean out the division.

[oldgringo]

Among the best 30 fighters to do it in my opinion.

[Boxingwizard]

Top 30. He's definitely not above SRR, Henry Armstrong, SRL, Tommy Hearns, Muhammad Ali, Hagler, JCC, and many other fighters.

[brian99]

Hes not going down in the books above rjj, lewis, hopkins, or maybe even dlh so hes def not the best of the generation. Id say top 50, but if he beats mosley and maybe cotto/wright then he's top 20.

[ottoevans]

ali,marciano,leonard,robinson,roy jones,duran,chavez,joe louis,hagler.... who else is out there?

[ROSEWOOD]

If Pretty Boy retires today he is definitely top 5..This dude is the GAME/SPORT today..no one in the game 154 on down will ever beat him..He will never lose a fight..

[boxer2k5]

berto?
dude has liek 15 fights no
belts never headlined a card
da hell is wrong with you

cotto is a psopect with a belt

non of the buys you listed besides
mosley could beat oscar

the only guy worth fighting besides oscar
rematch is mosley but a year n half ago they
was sayng mosley was shot and done
cuz he beats vargas n callazo he is a threat?

if floyd beat mosley 2 years ago it wouldnt mean nothing
but if he beats mosley now its something big