Mayweather or Mosley: Who is the More Accomplished Fighter?

[Technical_Skill]

Sorry big fella, but fighting two great fighters your whole career doesn't beat fighting 5-6 VERY good/great ones. Thats not even mentioning that Mosley lost to one of those great fighters twice and arguably lost one of the fights against the other.

You aint gettin my point, STILL

Im not talking about who won which fight or not, those are achivements and acomplishments,

Im talking about RESUME, who they have fought.

No one can deny Moesly fought the better fighters, please dont make me have to compare corrales to vargas, Winky to Judah, De La Hoya to Hernandez.

[ThaHorseman]

You aint gettin my point, STILL

Im not talking about who won which fight or not, those are achivements and acomplishments,

Im talking about RESUME, who they have fought.

No one can deny Moesly fought the better fighters, please dont make me have to compare corrales to vargas, Winky to Judah, De La Hoya to Hernandez.

I'm pretty sure I addressed your point that 2 great fighters does not equal 6 just below great fighters. Yes, Winky is the best fighter on both resumes and DLH is 2nd, but Judah, Corrales, Castillo, C. Hernandez, Chavez and G. Hernandez are all above Forrest and especially Vargas. As a whole, NOT JUST SELECTING A FEW FIGHTERS THAT MAKE YOUR POINT VALID, Mayweather has by a far a better OVERALL resume.

and please don't give the the whole "Forrest was in his prime" ****. Vernon's prime WAS Mosley. Thats says more about Mosley than it does Forrest.

[kayjay]

If it said 'more skilled' I could see people picking Mayweather, but in terms of accomplishment I don't see this as even close.

[Technical_Skill]

I'm pretty sure I addressed your point that 2 great fighters does not equal 6 just below great fighters. Yes, Winky is the best fighter on both resumes and DLH is 2nd, but Judah, Corrales, Castillo, C. Hernandez, Chavez and G. Hernandez are all above Forrest and especially Vargas. As a whole, NOT JUST SELECTING A FEW FIGHTERS THAT MAKE YOUR POINT VALID, Mayweather has by a far a better OVERALL resume.

and please don't give the the whole "Forrest was in his prime" ****. Vernon's prime WAS Mosley. Thats says more about Mosley than it does Forrest.

Hold on, are you saying Floyd mayweather has fought better fighters than Shane Mosley?

let me put it another way, just so people can comprehend this.

Are you saying PBF has fought harder Opposition than Shane Mosley?

Yes or no answer really.

[kayjay]

Judah, Corrales, Castillo, C. Hernandez, Chavez and G. Hernandez are all above Forrest and especially Vargas.

That there hardly goes without saying.

[ThaHorseman]

Hold on, are you saying Floyd mayweather has fought better fighters than Shane Mosley?

let me put it another way, just so people can comprehend this.

Are you saying PBF has fought harder Opposition than Shane Mosley?

Yes or no answer really.

Absolutely. Thoughout their careers, as a whole Floyd Mayweather has fought MUCH tougher competition than Shane Mosley.

[Technical_Skill]

Absolutely. Thoughout their careers, as a whole Floyd Mayweather has fought MUCH tougher competition than Shane Mosley.

Cool, i'll leave it at that so we can see what others think.

laters.

[Technical_Skill]

Cool, i'll leave it at that so we can see what others think.

laters.

Just for the record im saying that

Prime Winky Wright
Prime De La Hoya
Prime Vernon Forrest
Fernando Vargas

are tougher as a whole than the toughest fights PBF has had.

[ThaHorseman]

Just for the record im saying that

Prime Winky Wright
Prime De La Hoya
Prime Vernon Forrest
Fernando Vargas

are tougher as a whole than the toughest fights PBF has had.

just for the record thats exactly what I knew you were going to try to pull. AS A WHOLE. please tell me you see that. Like I said above, you can pick out a few fights to make your case. A resume is more than 4 fights. Thanks for wasting my time.

[Technical_Skill]

just for the record thats exactly what I knew you were going to try to pull. AS A WHOLE. please tell me you see that. Like I said above, you can pick out a few fights to make your case. A resume is more than 4 fights. Thanks for wasting my time.

Ok then, RESUME AS A WHOLE, because i think throughout their whole carrers Shane Moesly has been in the Tougher fights, the quality of opponents he fought shows that.

Either way Deliveryman is wrong, PBF is not WAY more accomplished than Mosley, its closer than that.

It's been done to death now, i like mayweather, he's my fav,

But im not a Floyd Mayweather groupie, hanging around non-stop boxing to see if anyone dares to challenge PBF, then jumping in mid-arguement to slag people off, and im not reffering to you personally, but you get the picture.

Im giving my honest opinion.

Laters.