Mayweather or Mosley: Who is the More Accomplished Fighter?

[Technical_Skill]

[QUOTE=deliveryman;2284537]Because Floyd hasn't lost 5 times.[QUOTE]

I disagree with your reasoning, and thats all i can say, I dont know Forrest's or Chop-chop's resume well, so im not the one you should be asking that question.

Im better placed to answer on shane and floyd's resume.

Its foolish for anyone to say PBF is WAY more accomplished than Shane, more accomplished yes, but not WAY more accomplished.

This is why i took issue with you.

If you think the best fighters Floyd faced : Zab Judah, Hernandez, Castillo and Corrales

are better than

A prime De La Hoya, Prime Winky Wright, Prime Vernon Forrest and Fernando Vargas

then i think quite a few other people on this board would also take issue with you.

No hard feelings.

[deliveryman]

[QUOTE=Technical_Skill;2284545][QUOTE=deliveryman;2284537]Because Floyd hasn't lost 5 times.

I disagree with your reasoning, and thats all i can say, I dont know Forrest's or Chop-chop's resume well, so im not the one you should be asking that question.

Im better placed to answer on shane and floyd's resume.

Its foolish for anyone to say PBF is WAY more accomplished than Shane, more accomplished yes, but not WAY more accomplished.

This is why i took issue with you.

If you think the best fighters Floyd faced : Zab Judah, Hernandez, Castillo and Corrales

are better than

A prime De La Hoya, Prime Winky Wright, Prime Vernon Forrest and Fernando Vargas

then i think quite a few other people on this board would also take issue with you.

No hard feelings.

Okay let me make this easier than:

Vernon Forrest:

L - Ike Quartey by UD, (they robbed Ike blind)
L (twice) - Ricardo Mayorga by MD and TKO.
W (twice) - Shane Mosley by UD
W - Vince Phillips by UD

DeMarcus Corley:

L - Junior Witter by UD
L - Miguel Cotto by TKO
L - Floyd Mayweather by UD
L - Zab Judah by UD

[ThaHorseman]

[QUOTE=Technical_Skill;2284545][QUOTE=deliveryman;2284537]Because Floyd hasn't lost 5 times.

I disagree with your reasoning, and thats all i can say, I dont know Forrest's or Chop-chop's resume well, so im not the one you should be asking that question.

Im better placed to answer on shane and floyd's resume.

Its foolish for anyone to say PBF is WAY more accomplished than Shane, more accomplished yes, but not WAY more accomplished.

This is why i took issue with you.

If you think the best fighters Floyd faced : Zab Judah, Hernandez, Castillo and Corrales

are better than

A prime De La Hoya, Prime Winky Wright, Prime Vernon Forrest and Fernando Vargas

then i think quite a few other people on this board would also take issue with you.

No hard feelings.

I see the point you are trying to make, but beating A- fighters (Hernandez, Castillo, Corrales, Judah) soundly trumps losing convincingly to A fighters (Winky) and B fighters (Forrest). When you are talking about a better RESUME, its about having the better fighters on the list. Mosley two great fighters and a two good ones. Floyd has a LOT of very good names.

[Technical_Skill]

I see the point you are trying to make, but beating A- fighters (Hernandez, Castillo, Corrales, Judah) soundly trumps losing convincingly to A fighters (Winky) and B fighters (Forrest). When you are talking about a better RESUME, its about having the better fighters on the list. Mosley two great fighters and a two good ones. Floyd has a LOT of very good names.

Moesly fought better fighters than PBF, therefore he has a better resume,

PBF has achieved more and is a more accomplised fighter than Mosley, but not WAY more accomplished.

Can you see that this is just common sense reasoning? lol

I dunno why some PBF fans are so defenisive, im a fan too, but not to the point where i agree with everything he says and does and will not critisize aspects of Floyd's resume.

It aint rocket science lol.

[GunStar]

PBF has achieved more and is a more accomplised fighter than Mosley, but not WAY more accomplished.

What the hell are you talking about???

[Technical_Skill]

What the hell are you talking about???

Deliveryman said PBF was 'way more accomplished than mosley' this is what i have taken note with.

Thus the comment i made, dont be a cheerleader fanboy for Deliveryman, let him speak for himself,

if you have a problem with what ive said, your welcome to take issue in a polite manner,

otherwise, see ya. lol.

[GunStar]

Deliveryman said PBF was 'way more accomplished than mosley' this is what i have taken note with.

Thus the comment i made, dont be a cheerleader fanboy for Deliveryman, let him speak for himself,

if you have a problem with what ive said, your welcome to take issue in a polite manner,

otherwise, see ya. lol.

I also said that he's more accomplished then Mosley and you were debating with me first.

I'm not cheerleading, it's just that I agree with his posts, he makes sense with his post unlike you!

[GunStar]

Anyway I've to go now, I hate repeating myself over and over like some people do here!

[ThaHorseman]

Moesly fought better fighters than PBF, therefore he has a better resume,

PBF has achieved more and is a more accomplised fighter than Mosley, but not WAY more accomplished.

Can you see that this is just common sense reasoning? lol

I dunno why some PBF fans are so defenisive, im a fan too, but not to the point where i agree with everything he says and does and will not critisize aspects of Floyd's resume.

It aint rocket science lol.

Sorry big fella, but fighting two great fighters your whole career doesn't beat fighting 5-6 VERY good/great ones. Thats not even mentioning that Mosley lost to one of those great fighters twice and arguably lost one of the fights against the other.

[Run]

since you Floyd nuthuggers always use the "Judah is better than everyone Margarito beat" line.

Mosley beat Oscar. End of thread.

Funny thing is......half of you are using that same double standard. Oscar is better than anyone Floyd has ever faced times ten.



Never pay again for live sex! | Hot girls doing naughty stuff for free! | Chat for free!