Mayweather or Mosley: Who is the More Accomplished Fighter?

[ThaHorseman]

The Vargas victory could be compared to the Gatti victory. Two guys who are battle-tested, but removed from being much more than a name. Forrest is like a lot of guys Floyd fought. He won a lot of fights against less than stellar competition, earned his shot and hasn't done **** since. N'Dou, Sosa, and Baldomir come to mind. The difference is that Floyd handled his business and Mosley didn't. The point is, STOP PUTTING VARGAS AND FORREST IN THE CONVERSATION OF BEING TOP COMPETITION.

[Parody]

No it wont, mosley still beat vargas and vargas is faded but hes still a very bigger stronger dangerous fighter than anyone Mayweather has ever faced

No he's not. Vargas was shot to pieces and everyone knew that even before the fight happened.

[Tha_Greatest]

This polls shows how dumb the Mayweather haters are here!

This polls shows how dumb the Mosley haters are here too, i h8 both these guys but Mosley deserves his proper credit

[Parody]

Mosley only has one good name in his resume and thats oscar, oscar got robbed in the second fight.

Without the oscar win It's not even close, without oscar Mosley would'nt be a superstar... After May 5th we can decide who's resume is better and who is the more accomplished fighter.

[GunStar]

This polls shows how dumb the Mosley haters are here too, i h8 both these guys but Mosley deserves his proper credit

Actually I like Mosley and I don't even hate the guy, it's just that all Mayweather haters here at Boxingscene really don't know boxing.

A famous fighter does not prove he's a better fighter then someone that is not famous!

[Technical_Skill]

Mosley only has one good name in his resume and thats oscar, oscar got robbed in the second fight.

Sorry, is Winky Wright a good fighter to have on your resume?

[-EX-]

But Mosley lost to Winky twice.

[Technical_Skill]

Actually I like Mosley and I don't even hate the guy, it's just that all Mayweather haters here at Boxingscene really don't know boxing.

It's a forum, its made for difference of opinion, just because a persons opinion differs from your, does not mean 'they dont know about boxing' lol. However yes some people here do have an irrational dislike for PBF.

A famous fighter does not prove he's a better fighter then someone that is not famous!

This i agree with.

[Technical_Skill]

But Mosley lost to Winky twice.

Yup, didnt know you guys were still concentrating on who he has and has not beat, i dont why people keep holding these losses against Moesly, he got them by taking risks and fighting better fighters than Floyd, more than once.

Floyd is more skilled
Floyd has achieved more
Floyd is more accomplished

But Mosley had the tougher fights.

And thats still my opinion.

I dont mind those whose opinions differ from mine.

[GunStar]

It's a forum, its made for difference of opinion, just because a persons opinion differs from your, does not mean 'they dont know about boxing' lol. However yes some people here do have an irrational dislike for PBF.

I know it's a forum and I agree you should have your own opnion, it's just that I see this as a no brainer.