Calzaghe or Hopkins: Whose 20 Defenses Were Better?

[kayjay]

It's close, really.

[Brother Blues]

Hopkins has wins over Trinidad and Dela Hoya...does anyone on Calzaghe's list come close to those two?...of course not.Calzaghe has never risked anything...which is why he not one of the 'big boys',and is just a boy.

[GEOFFHAYES]

Is this some kind of joke?

This isn't even close.

Calzaghe by landslide.

[CoLd_WaVE]

Is this some kind of joke?

This isn't even close.

Calzaghe by landslide.

L M A O

[iron mike tyson]

the biggest names on hopkins lists where natural a welterwieght and a person who started at super featherwieght and whos best wieght was welterwieght . take tito and oscar away and calzaghes blows hopkins away but with them you can argue for hopkins. another thing that goes for hopkins is he cleaned up the division ad claimed all 4 major belts on the way , that looks very nice on paper but in retrospect it aint brilliant considering who he beat for the belts.
id pick hopkins because of the name value of de la hoya and trinidad

[kayjay]

Hopkins has wins over Trinidad and Dela Hoya...does anyone on Calzaghe's list come close to those two?...of course not.Calzaghe has never risked anything...which is why he not one of the 'big boys',and is just a boy.

DLH is one of my favorute fighters but I don't rate that as a huge win for Hopkins. DLH at middleweight was a joke.

[Pugilistic™]

hopkins is my choice

[deliveryman]

Hopkins, and easily.

[kayjay]

Even the Eubank that faced Calzaghe is a much better win than the DLH who fought Hopkins.

[number6]

Hopkins gets my vote but i dont think there's a great deal in it.