H2H who was the greatest Super-Middleweight ever

[sonnyboyx2]

H2H with all fighters in their prime:

Roy Jones Jr.
James Toney
Joe Calzaghe
Sven Ottke
Nigel Benn
Chris Eubank
Sugar Ray Leonard
Thomas Hearns
Steve Collins
Michael Nunn

[StarshipTrooper]

Bogus division: I put SMs in with the Light-Heavies.

Poet

[CarlosG815]

It is Roy Jones Jr.

Hearns shouldn't even be on that list.

[sonnyboyx2]

It is Roy Jones Jr.

Hearns shouldn't even be on that list.

All fighters on the list was Super-Middleweight world champion

[XionComrade]

No Gerald Mcclellan? I would pick him personally, but went with Jones.

[CarlosG815]

No Gerald Mcclellan? I would pick him personally, but went with Jones.

He had one fight at SMW and it was the one that ended his career. He is mentally slow, blind and half deaf. How do you pick him to be the greatest H2H super middleweight?

[Barn]

Roy Jones Jr in my opinion, easily his best weight packed a heavy punch, blinding speed and rarely got hit.

[BattlingNelson]

H2H it's between Calzaghe and RJJ. I go with the latter.

[XionComrade]

He had one fight at SMW and it was the one that ended his career. He is mentally slow, blind and half deaf. How do you pick him to be the greatest H2H super middleweight?

I know all of this. And even with a massive tangerine sized blood clot in his brain he still battered Benn to near death, Benn was as near death as Mcclellan was after that fight and Mcclellan's brain was imploding. I cannot realistically see anyone having Benn on this list without Mcclellan who probably would have damn near killed him if it wasn't for the blood clot he had been carrying since the first Jackson fight. It kicked in around round 3 and Mcclellan was still ahead on the scorecards and in much better physical shape than Benn, who was down and out shortly before the stoppage >.<

[Joeyzagz]

Joe Calzaghe and Jones are practically the same age, and I believe the same result would occur any time they fought.

We know Roy Jones was a steroid user in his prime. In a fair testing environment, he would lose everytime to Calzaghe.