Ron Lyle or Ray Mercer Who do you rate higher on your greatest Heavyweight's list?
Collapse
-
Comment
-
Comment
-
No shame in losing to an old Ali. Getting stopped by him is a different matter entirely. Especially if you're considered "40th greatest Heavyweight of all time".(Ring Magazine rating in 1998 from memory).
And Mercer's physical shape must be accounted for in his sub par performances. It's a notable difference from just having a lack of talent.Comment
-
No shame in losing to an old Ali. Getting stopped by him is a different matter entirely. Especially if you're considered "40th greatest Heavyweight of all time".(Ring Magazine rating in 1998 from memory).
And Mercer's physical shape must be accounted for in his sub par performances. It's a notable difference from just having a lack of talent.Comment
-
I think the prime Lyle would have beaten the Holmes that beat Mercer. And Mercer was in his prime for that fight so there are no excuses for it.Comment
-
A) Lewis won his fight with Mercer more comfortably than history remembers.
B) The Ali-Lyle stoppage was premature.
That much aside, while I have a pretty healthy respect for Mercer, I do feel he is often over-rated. There may not be streets in it, but looking at their careers & better performances, I feel comfortable saying the line in the sand is a fairly clear one --- Lyle was the better fighter.Comment
-
Comment
-
Comment
Comment