Greatest Round Robin you Could Make

[DeeMoney]

What is the greatest 4-man round robin you could make using any boxers in history?

By which I mean if you could choose any four fighters and have them each fight each other, over say a 9-month span, which fighters would produce both the highest quality, and most exciting fights?

For the sake of discussion, you can set weight limits wherever you want even if it wasnt a wt class that existed when a certain fighter was fighting (ie a 200lb round robin and include Marciano, or a Jr Welter round robin and have Henry Armstrong). Though fighters should be fighting near their actual weight class- I dont think Salvador Sanchez at Lt Heavy really works.

So which four fighters give us the highest quality and excitement?

[Willie Pep 229]

For Excitment

MQB Rules

Four rounds ND fights.

35-15% Winner-Loser gate split.

For ND Fights, fighters split gate 20-20%. Remaining gate (10%) rolls over to championship round (Fight Night #5.)

A. Marciano
B. Jeffries
C. Dempsey
D. Frazier

Five Fight Nights over 18 months.

Fight Night 1: A-B / C-D
Fight Night 2: A-C / B-D
Fight Night 3: A-D / B-C

Fighters are now seeded based on win-loss record. 1 to 4 seeds.

Fight Night 4: Semi-Finals: 1-4 /2-3

Fight Night 5: Championship: (Winner of 1-4 vs. Winner of 2-3) for Gold. (Loser of 1-4 vs. Loser of 2-3) for Bronze.

Gold: 35% of gate plus roll over.
Silver: 30% of gate plus roll over
Bronze: 20% of gate plus roll over.
Steel: 15% of gate plus roll over

[Bronson66]

What is the greatest 4-man round robin you could make using any boxers in history?

By which I mean if you could choose any four fighters and have them each fight each other, over say a 9-month span, which fighters would produce both the highest quality, and most exciting fights?

For the sake of discussion, you can set weight limits wherever you want even if it wasnt a wt class that existed when a certain fighter was fighting (ie a 200lb round robin and include Marciano, or a Jr Welter round robin and have Henry Armstrong). Though fighters should be fighting near their actual weight class- I dont think Salvador Sanchez at Lt Heavy really works.

So which four fighters give us the highest quality and excitement?

Interesting concept.
Only Champions. Matching guys I think could be guaranteed to provide action and excitement
Dempsey, Louis ,Marciano,Frazier.Hvy

Moore,Foster,Spinks,Beterbiev . Lhvy

Lamotta,Zale,Ketchel,Tiger.Middle.

Robinson,Hearns,Walker,Trinidad.Welter

Duran,Williams,Jack,Chavez. Light

Armstrong,Saddler,Arguello,Pacquiano .Feather

Olivares,Zarate,Jofre ,Inuoe. Bantam.

Lynch,Wilde,Perez,Harada.Fly

[QueensburyRules]

What is the greatest 4-man round robin you could make using any boxers in history?

By which I mean if you could choose any four fighters and have them each fight each other, over say a 9-month span, which fighters would produce both the highest quality, and most exciting fights?

For the sake of discussion, you can set weight limits wherever you want even if it wasnt a wt class that existed when a certain fighter was fighting (ie a 200lb round robin and include Marciano, or a Jr Welter round robin and have Henry Armstrong). Though fighters should be fighting near their actual weight class- I dont think Salvador Sanchez at Lt Heavy really works.

So which four fighters give us the highest quality and excitement?

- - Pretty much had one with Ali/Joe/George/Ken though Joe wouldn't fight Ken because he was training Ken.