Frazier v Marciano The Ring's Verdict.

Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Ivich
    Banned
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • Jun 2013
    • 4377
    • 1,640
    • 2,302
    • 6,015

    #1

    Frazier v Marciano The Ring's Verdict.

    Frazier drops Marciano in the 1st rd with a left hook.Frazier ,with the size,and strength advantage initially make it a onesided fight.

    Marciano is cut over both eyes and taking heavy punishment,but in the 4th rd he lands a big right cross that floors Frazier for a 9 count.

    Mid way into the 6th a right splits open Marciano's nose and the fight is stopped.
  • them_apples
    Lord
    Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
    • Aug 2007
    • 9794
    • 1,185
    • 900
    • 41,722

    #2
    Originally posted by Ivich
    Frazier drops Marciano in the 1st rd with a left hook.Frazier ,with the size,and strength advantage initially make it a onesided fight.

    Marciano is cut over both eyes and taking heavy punishment,but in the 4th rd he lands a big right cross that floors Frazier for a 9 count.

    Mid way into the 6th a right splits open Marciano's nose and the fight is stopped.
    Frazier will fight inside because he has no choice. And in doing this gets slaughtered. Beat up BAD. You don’t stand in front of Marciano, his 68 reach gives him an enormous advantage among other things. Joe won’t stop him and likely won’t land the kind of mustard you think he will.

    I think early on the fight is competitive or appears so, but at about round 8 it starts taking a nose dive and Joe get’s hurt and stopped. Marciano will be too strong.

    Joe was downing a bottle of JD on the regular, Marciano was running 15 miles with sand weighted boots in hill country an denying Jane Mansfield.

    all you can see is 186 lbs but it’s not gonna matter. He’s a literal gladiator. Lived a spartan life.

    Comment

    • Ivich
      Banned
      Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
      • Jun 2013
      • 4377
      • 1,640
      • 2,302
      • 6,015

      #3
      Originally posted by them_apples

      Frazier will fight inside because he has no choice. And in doing this gets slaughtered. Beat up BAD. You donāt stand in front of Marciano, his 68 reach gives him an enormous advantage among other things. Joe wonāt stop him and likely wonāt land the kind of mustard you think he will.

      I think early on the fight is competitive or appears so, but at about round 8 it starts taking a nose dive and Joe getās hurt and stopped. Marciano will be too strong.

      Joe was downing a bottle of JD on the regular, Marciano was running 15 miles with sand weighted boots in hill country an denying Jane Mansfield.

      all you can see is 186 lbs but itās not gonna matter. Heās a literal gladiator. Lived a spartan life.
      I haven't given my opinion.That is the Ring's prediction.

      This running 15 miles ,you quote it as though he did it all time,he didn't nor did he wear weighted boots,just like he never hit a 300lbs bag for 30 rounds after sparring.

      I've posted boxing writers of the Ring's opinion of the outcome .
      If you weren't so frantically anxious to rush and defend your idol you might have taken the time to actually read and digest it!

      Comment

      • DooGee#33
        Contender
        Silver Champion - 100-500 posts
        • Sep 2023
        • 114
        • 66
        • 78
        • 0

        #4
        Frazier was the more accurate, precise puncher. I think his accuracy would spell doom whereMarciano is concerned. I dont think his facial features would hold up well. Rocky would always be dangerous but Joe was every bit as tough and can match Rocky's legendary stamina.

        Comment

        • Ivich
          Banned
          Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
          • Jun 2013
          • 4377
          • 1,640
          • 2,302
          • 6,015

          #5
          Originally posted by DooGee#33
          Frazier was the more accurate, precise puncher. I think his accuracy would spell doom whereMarciano is concerned. I dont think his facial features would hold up well. Rocky would always be dangerous but Joe was every bit as tough and can match Rocky's legendary stamina.
          Frazier's accuracy and Marciano's lack of it are seldom mentioned.

          Comment

          • them_apples
            Lord
            Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
            • Aug 2007
            • 9794
            • 1,185
            • 900
            • 41,722

            #6
            Originally posted by Ivich

            I haven't given my opinion.That is the Ring's prediction.

            This running 15 miles ,you quote it as though he did it all time,he didn't nor did he wear weighted boots,just like he never hit a 300lbs bag for 30 rounds after sparring.

            I've posted boxing writers of the Ring's opinion of the outcome .
            If you weren't so frantically anxious to rush and defend your idol you might have taken the time to actually read and digest it!
            You got that from a forum search off ******** boxing. Yes he did do those things.

            Comment

            • them_apples
              Lord
              Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
              • Aug 2007
              • 9794
              • 1,185
              • 900
              • 41,722

              #7
              Originally posted by Ivich

              I haven't given my opinion.That is the Ring's prediction.

              This running 15 miles ,you quote it as though he did it all time,he didn't nor did he wear weighted boots,just like he never hit a 300lbs bag for 30 rounds after sparring.

              I've posted boxing writers of the Ring's opinion of the outcome .
              If you weren't so frantically anxious to rush and defend your idol you might have taken the time to actually read and digest it!
              I change my response. Frazier rocks Marciano early with a vicious left hook. Immediately after marciano keeps a strong hard pace and begins to pulverize frazier, who gets hurt bad at the end of the round and stopped bad the very next round. Absolute hopeless match for Joe Frazier

              Comment

              • Ivich
                Banned
                Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                • Jun 2013
                • 4377
                • 1,640
                • 2,302
                • 6,015

                #8
                Originally posted by them_apples

                You got that from a forum search off ******** boxing. Yes he did do those things.
                Nope I got it from 2003 Ring magazine,Dream Fights Vol 2 as I said and it's here on my desk as a type this.
                The other matchups are as follows;
                Dempsey v Louis

                Ali v Tyson page10

                Liston v Holyfield page18

                Tunney v Johnson page 20

                Holmes v Walcott page22


                And so on .There are 50 matchups all together.

                If you are going to imply I am a liar you better be able to ****ing prove it.

                Now lets have some proof Marciano hit a 300lbs bag for 30 rds after his daily sparring session and that he ran15 miles uphill in weighted boots,because neither are mentioned in the 4 books of Marciano I have read.

                You will note I haven't implied you are a liar after you posted these fairy tales.

                NEXT TIME!

                Comment

                • Ivich
                  Banned
                  Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                  • Jun 2013
                  • 4377
                  • 1,640
                  • 2,302
                  • 6,015

                  #9
                  Originally posted by them_apples

                  Frazier will fight inside because he has no choice. And in doing this gets slaughtered. Beat up BAD. You donāt stand in front of Marciano, his 68 reach gives him an enormous advantage among other things. Joe wonāt stop him and likely wonāt land the kind of mustard you think he will.

                  I think early on the fight is competitive or appears so, but at about round 8 it starts taking a nose dive and Joe getās hurt and stopped. Marciano will be too strong.

                  Joe was downing a bottle of JD on the regular, Marciano was running 15 miles with sand weighted boots in hill country an denying Jane Mansfield.

                  all you can see is 186 lbs but itās not gonna matter. Heās a literal gladiator. Lived a spartan life.
                  Frazier was not downing bottles of JD when he was fighting Ali,Ellis,and Quarry, and Marciano has no choice but to fight inside either.

                  Frazier set a faster pace than Marciano and he had no problem maintaining that pace ,he also had faster hands.plus did not cut,and was more accurate with his punches.
                  Added to which he had15lbs on Rocky.

                  I tentatively pick Marciano to win because he was a two handed puncher, and Frazier mainly relied on his left hook, but this fight could go either way imo.

                  Stating Frazier gets slaughtered in a couple of rounds as your last post says is absurd fanboyism .

                  Do you think Liston ,Foreman,Lewis,would not stand in front of Marciano? Do you see them boxing of the back foot against him?

                  HERE ARE MY SOURCES.WHERE ARE YOURS?
                  • ;dr: He ran 3-5 miles per day and ate plenty of food. His big workout apparently lasted around 90 minutes (from 3-4:30).


                    from Harold Kaese, “In a Game That’s Noted for Its Punks, Phoneys, Rocky Stands for Class, Boston Globe (Sept. 20, 1952), p.7


                    “[…] Marciano is satisfied if he has a few close friends and a pantry near him.

                    He is eating all the way, although Al Colombo, a pal, thinks Rocky’s knife-and-fork exercises have been exaggerated.

                    “He’s over-rated,” said Colombo, adding alertly, I mean as an eater, not a fighter.”

                    Colombo’s revelation that Marciano does not eat eight lamb chops for breakfast but only two or three was sworn to by Alfred Renault, the camp’s chef. […]

                    Marciano, who only skipped rope today, said he was not nervous, “only a little tense like I always am before a fight.” This he admitted, was his big opportunity and concluded, “I don’t intend to lose it.”

                    Each day for a month, Marciano has got up at 7 a.m. He then has a cup of tea (sugar and lemon) and usually runs between three and five miles.

                    At 8:30, it is a breakfast of fruit, cereal, two soft-boiled eggs, lamb chops, toast, and more tea.

                    He walks and naps until noon, when he has some tea.

                    Then he naps until his big workout at 3 p.m. After 4:30 he naps until dinner time at 5:30; after which he walks, plays ping pong, reads, or listens to the radio. At 8:30 he may have an apple or pear, and goes to bed.

                    According to Reinault, the meat is usually steak or roast beef—rare. Lamb, veal, and a little chicken for variety. Baked potatoes, green vegetables, and plenty of salads with oil and vinegar dressing. Oh yes—tea.

                    No Italian foods. No pork. No pastry. No ice cream.

                    Reinault, who came to this country from Germany in 1923, also cooked here for Joey Maxim before the Robinson fight. The difference he said, was “Maxim had to lose weight, so he ate less and ran more than this fellow.”

                    Marciano has not been training for a race. He wants to win only one letter against Walcott—in boxing, not track.”




                    In his camp for Charles II, he was doing 5 miles a day according to the Boston Daily Record.

                    In his camp for Moore, according to Pete Coutros (reprinted in the Omaha World Herald) he was doing 6 mile runs.

                    The Detroit Times claims he did 320 miles of roadwork in 7 weeks for Walcott I. That's right about 45 miles a week or 6.5 miles a day.

                    For Walcott II, the AP goes over his entire daily training routine. The only roadwork is 5 miles of combined running and walking with buddy Al Columbo.​
                  • L;DR Rocky Marciano's Training Routine
                  • 7 am: Wake up, drink tea with sugar and lemon, and run 5 miles (9km)
                  • 8:30 am: Breakfast includes fruit, cereal, two soft-boiled eggs, lamb chops, toast, and tea.
                  • 10 am: Short walk and nap
                  • 12 pm: another short nap before his workout
                  • 3 pm: Boxing workout, including push-ups, pull-ups, and other calisthenics exercises
                  • 4:30 pm: Another short nap before dinner
                  • 5 pm: Dinner including steak, green vegetables, and olive oil dressing
                  • 7 pm: Walk, ping pong, reading or listening to the radio
                  • 8:30 pm: An apple or a pear, and then time for bed

                  • .
                  Last edited by Ivich; 05-11-2024, 04:29 AM.

                  Comment

                  • Ivich
                    Banned
                    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                    • Jun 2013
                    • 4377
                    • 1,640
                    • 2,302
                    • 6,015

                    #10
                    Originally posted by Willie Pep 229

                    Thanks for posting that. Good read. It doesn't address the isolation I yawned on about a few posts back.

                    P.S. I love that the very last line of Marciano's Walcott camp training routine: "He wants to win only one letter . . ." Is a reference to 'varsity sports.' I wonder how many kids today would understand what winning a varsity "letter" means.
                    At our top colleges they are called "blues".
                    Marciano had a little rubber ball on elastic fixed over his chest when he was in bed and he would hit it before sleeping.
                    The guy was a compulsive.
                    Last edited by Ivich; 05-12-2024, 12:52 AM.

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    TOP