Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Roy Jones 193lbs v A J,Fury,Bowe,Lewis,Wlad ,and Vitali

Collapse
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #11
    Originally posted by Ivich View Post

    He had a brittle chin too!
    - - Not so as his outrageously stellar prime testifies to.

    Had he retired when he first contemplated retirement before the Ruiz fight where his trainer said his reflexes and timing were slowing down, he'd be regarded as #1 p4p in history.

    Comment


    • #12
      Originally posted by Dr. Z View Post

      This is Roy Jones big enough to beat recnet champions. My answer is no, but as history shows three + men beat Lous and Johnson that were Jones size.

      Did you not seek replies? I gave you mine.
      Yes I sought replies about Jones' chances against the heavyweights I named.At no time did I mention Johnson or Louis.

      Comment


      • #13
        Originally posted by QueensburyRules View Post

        - - Not so as his outrageously stellar prime testifies to.

        Had he retired when he first contemplated retirement before the Ruiz fight where his trainer said his reflexes and timing were slowing down, he'd be regarded as #1 p4p in history.
        No he would not. His ko losses to Tarver and Johnson showed that when his reflexes had eroded at 35 his chin could not hold up to a big shot.

        Comment


        • #14
          Originally posted by Ivich View Post

          No he would not. His ko losses to Tarver and Johnson showed that when his reflexes had eroded at 35 his chin could not hold up to a big shot.
          Jones didnā€™t need to bulk up, he just wanted to. A light heavy Jones would beat ruiz as well. The whole game plan for him was stick and move. Because nobody had any proof or study to the effects of bulking - they just assumed it would benefit Jones at HW. Another factor is Jones was very likely just on PEDs. Coming down in weight he probably dropped the peds, and without proper recooperation time to adjust to the lighterweight and no drugs - it weakened him

          Comment


          • #15
            Originally posted by Ivich View Post
            Posters have held Roy Jones victory over Ruiz as proof that a smaller man ,[Marciano,] can beat a modern sized class heavyweight. Now I want to match that version of Jones against the following
            Joshua
            Fury
            Bowe
            Lewis
            Wlad
            Vitali

            Six fights how many does he win?
            Jones isnĆ¢Ā€Ā™t even a former light heavy, no heĆ¢Ā€Ā™s a former middleweight at his best, and even started at 154.

            he is a very talented fighter though, and this is why he was able to beat Ruiz who is much larger than himself.

            even if you think it was only possible with bulk, never forget that Jones was STILL under 200 lbs. and 5 ft 10. He was a very small heavyweight, one of the smallest ever if we go by frame size. HeĆ¢Ā€Ā™s got the hands and head of a middleweight because thats what he is.

            These are very hard fights to predict because of the power of the real heavyweights vs a middleweight chin.

            if Jones can avoid getting caught he has a chance to beat these guys , with Joshua being the easiest (we saw him lose to usyk and Jones is better than Usyk) and Wlad the second easiest and Fury is a pickem (would be an awkward fight) Those first 2 are robots and donā€™t have any tricks whatsoever, so all Jones has to do is fight smart.

            the rest probably get him, but not just because they are big, its because they are also strong and hard punchers and Jones has a middleweight chin. Nobody ever said real size wasnā€™t a factor. It is, but itā€™s a small factor among many. It means very little.
            Last edited by them_apples; 04-11-2024, 06:06 PM.

            Comment


            • #16
              Originally posted by Willow The Wisp View Post
              Jones is too small for all those guys.

              Although....he has a decent shot against Vitali.
              What Chris Byrd did, Jones might very well be able to duplicate.
              You mean lose every rd and hope Vitali's shoulder gives out and the fight is stopped?

              Love Roy, he is a once in a century type of talent but he would lose probably by stoppage against all of the fighters mentioned.
              Ivich Ivich likes this.

              Comment


              • #17
                Originally posted by them_apples View Post

                Jones isnĆ¢ĀĀt even a former light heavy, no heĆ¢ĀĀs a former middleweight at his best, and even started at 154.

                he is a very talented fighter though, and this is why he was able to beat Ruiz who is much larger than himself.

                even if you think it was only possible with bulk, never forget that Jones was STILL under 200 lbs. and 5 ft 10. He was a very small heavyweight, one of the smallest ever if we go by frame size. HeĆ¢ĀĀs got the hands and head of a middleweight because thats what he is.

                These are very hard fights to predict because of the power of the real heavyweights vs a middleweight chin.

                if Jones can avoid getting caught he has a chance to beat these guys , with Joshua being the easiest (we saw him lose to usyk and Jones is better than Usyk) and Wlad the second easiest and Fury is a pickem (would be an awkward fight) Those first 2 are robots and donāt have any tricks whatsoever, so all Jones has to do is fight smart.

                the rest probably get him, but not just because they are big, its because they are also strong and hard punchers and Jones has a middleweight chin. Nobody ever said real size wasnāt a factor. It is, but itās a small factor among many. It means very little.
                Jack Johnson started his career as a middleweight,but I've never heard him referred to as,"a former middleweight."

                Likewise Archie Moore began boxing at welterweight should we say Marciano was knocked down and stunned so that he blacked out for a couple of seconds [by his own admission,I have the radio interview transcript,] by a "former welterweight?

                How big in circumference is Jones head? How big are his fists?

                You continuously make statements but never offer any proof of them .
                Just like when you said that, after sparring Marciano did 30 rds on the 300lbs bag.I'm still waiting for the proof of this that I requested from you.
                If size meant "very little," as you say.Why bother with weight divisions?Why bother with weigh ins? Why fine fighters who fail to make contracted weights?
                There is no logic to your arguments.
                Last edited by Ivich; 04-11-2024, 07:20 PM.

                Comment


                • #18
                  Originally posted by them_apples View Post

                  Jones didnāt need to bulk up, he just wanted to. A light heavy Jones would beat ruiz as well. The whole game plan for him was stick and move. Because nobody had any proof or study to the effects of bulking - they just assumed it would benefit Jones at HW. Another factor is Jones was very likely just on PEDs. Coming down in weight he probably dropped the peds, and without proper recooperation time to adjust to the lighterweight and no drugs - it weakened him
                  According to you and Margarino,lighter means faster and also means you have more stamina,so why did Jones forego that advantage against Ruiz.? Did he not know what you and Margarino know ?

                  You say he bulked up, just," because he wanted to."
                  You say Ellis,Byrd,M Spinks,Holyfield , Hay,and Usyk bulked up because they don't know how to fight.

                  Slugfester said they did it," because its the vogue" None of you will admit they did it to be able to compete with heavier men,to not be bullied in the clinches and to better be able to absorb the punches of bigger men.When in fact everyone who follows boxing knows this was the case!



                  There is no sense to your argument.
                  Last edited by Ivich; 04-11-2024, 07:27 PM.

                  Comment


                  • #19
                    He will likely beat Joshua and the pumped up Klits.

                    Comment


                    • #20
                      Originally posted by Willow The Wisp View Post
                      Jones is too small for all those guys.

                      Although....he has a decent shot against Vitali.
                      What Chris Byrd did, Jones might very well be able to duplicate.
                      Hanging in there long enough for Vitali to break his arm off of Roy and retire in his corner?
                      billeau2 billeau2 likes this.

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      X
                      TOP