RJJ vs Ezzard Charles LHW Title who wins?

[wmute]

Didn't Charles kill a fighter @ LH??

At that weight he had speed AND power. He also owned Charley Burley whom no one was looking to fight then.

Charles by a mid round TKO. It would take him a few rounds to slow RJJ down with his body work and ring generalship.

Charles also ko's a prime Archie Moore.

Truth to be told, he was a bigger man than Burley was.

Still, I think Charles is the only man who Burley could not beat (I think, correct me if I am wrong).

[Sweet Pete]

The 25 losses comment is enough to guarantee Hank Kaplan a place on my ignore list.

Again, I said that in response to cuzfozzy's ignorant comment.

[robjr]

Ezzard Charles





RJJ





you decide...

[wmute]

Again, I said that in response to cuzfozzy's ignorant comment.

ok, in view of this I will remove you from the list, but can I ask you why do you even feel the need to answer posts like "dem was real fighters"?

[Sweet Pete]

ok, in view of this I will remove you from the list, but can I ask you why do you even feel the need to answer posts like "dem was real fighters"?

To disprove everything cuzfozzy says, because he is always wrong.

[wmute]

Ezzard Charles





RJJ





you decide...

And when you decide,

remember that all of Charles fights come after he killed a man in the ring, and they are all HW fights,in which Charles was the smaller man.

In the first fight Charles gave away 14 pounds (181-195)
In the second 6.5 (182-188.5)
In the third 8 (185-193)
In the forth 7 (188-195)
In the last he has a 9 pound weight advantage (189-190)

Roy Jones highlights are all from fights between 160 and 175, except from the Ruiz fight.

[wmute]

To disprove everything cuzfozzy says, because he is always wrong.

Is he? I dont know, he has been on my ignore list pretty much ever since he graced the boards with his sophisticated posts. ;P

[Sweet Pete]

And when you decide,

remember that all of Charles fights come after he killed a man in the ring, and they are all HW fights,in which Charles was the smaller man.

In the first fight Charles gave away 14 pounds (181-195)
In the second 6.5 (182-188.5)
In the third 8 (185-193)
In the forth 7 (188-195)
In the last he has a 9 pound weight advantage (189-190)

Roy Jones highlights are all from fights between 160 and 175, except from the Ruiz fight.

This is a fight between the 2 at 175 though, so what they did at higher weights means nothing, and what they accomplished in their careers means nothing, how they match up with each other in a head to head clash is the only thing someone should be taking into account. It's called analyzing a fight, not analyzing their careers.

[wmute]

This is a fight between the 2 at 175 though, so what they did at higher weights means nothing, and what they accomplished in their careers means nothing, how they match up with each other in a head to head clash is the only thing someone should be taking into account. It's called analyzing a fight, not analyzing their careers.

I understand that, but the viewer should know that he is seeing Jones murdering middleweights-lightheavyweights and Charles knocking out heavyweights.

Say I show you highlights of Calderon and highlights of Jermain Taylor. Taylor surely looks worse, but he is 50 pounds heavier.

[THE REED]

with a match-up like this, the #1 thing to look at is styles... styles makes fights... charles back then was a killer for other people who would stand there and trade with him.. if you stood there and traded you were done for... we all know rjj isnt standing anywhere and trading, until he knows he can... i say if charles LITERALLY stepped in the ring with rjj... hed be a deer in head lights.... it would be SRL vs Duran all over again.... "**** this im outta here".., no not literally but... a fighter with a style like charles, who is used to fighting other fighters of that time period, would have never seen a fighter like jones... wouldnt know what to do... too fast... charles would come , and roy would be gone.... roy on the other hand, altho maybe not seeing the EXACT fighter of charles' capability... he has seen charles' style before.. and he has beat it

rjj ud

and everyone on this forum is entitled to an opinion... especially on a fight that never and WILL never take place... so dont start adding people to your ignore list because there disagreences... its a boxing forum, people have their own opinions on everything