Perhaps none was entirely right, but let’s look at it objectively. It is not so much about what you say and do, but how you say it and do it. It’s true Freddy was impatient, short tempered, and too reactive, but Robert was using the gym on Roach’s time, was giving interviews, and was totally uncooperative. In black and white, it was Roach’s time to use the gym. If team Rios decided to do interviews during their gym time, it’s their fault. Robert had sent Rios to the elliptical for half an hour one minute before Freddy showed up and it is safe to assume that he meant Rios to be on the machine for the 30 minutes, plus the time to cool down, pack up, and stretch (or whatever else it is that Ariza does to fighters). So they might’ve grossly trespass upon Roach’s time for quite some time.
It is also true that Freddy Roach lost his cool quickly enough, but Garcia was being deliberately uncooperative, he was unyielding to any request, he was not looking at Roach when he was being addressed, he was the epitome of a mule saying NO, NO, NO! (Not literally). What was Freddy to do, call his dad? I agree there are more civilized ways to settle that problem, but these are fighters, and they sometime react accordingly. I also agree with the poster who said this was a set up for Roach to flip over. Sometimes just being ignored and especially when you’re right (Freddy could prove that it was his time to use the gym) can be irritating to some people, and it seemed that Freddy is one of those people.
I am not trying to clear Roach of all wrongdoing, but Garcia sometimes strikes me as a sort of fake nice guy who sometimes acts through his fighters. I mean, a good amount of a……s seem to gravitate towards him and his gym, and seem to have pretty good chemistry with him. For every decent guy like Mickey and Maidana he has a Margarito, a Rios, or a Vargas. It was him egging Rios on to imitate Roach on that video before the Pac-Marg fight, so trying to say he has never disrespected Roach is not precisely accurate. He just tried to play the political correctness card, like he was trying to be conciliatory, reaching to Roach, when in fact, he was simply and purposely obstructing team Pac’s access to the gym.
Bringing Ariza to the team was like Mayweather inviting Rios to the Ortiz bout. But it is justifiable since Rios has had so many weight issues in the past, and anyways, they may bring whoever they want to camp. But being the head of the camp, he should have put Ariza on check before the escalation. In my humble opinion, Robert was simply a very smooth operator who, to anyone who does not follow boxing very closely, was made to look like the good guy who did nothing to upset Roach, and Freddy was the grumpy, impatient, and xenophobic guy who exploded for no reason. So, the casuals who do not follow the build up to fights, the training camps, and all other peripheral boxing activities, Garcia came out better. Let everyone draw their own conclusions.
Sorry for long and tiresome post.