Who ranks higher on your ATG list? Floyd Mayweather or Ricky Hatton

Hey threadstarter....... https://media3.giphy.com/media/13ATyLQB0rLVzG/giphy.gif

Ricky Hatton no, but Matthew Hatton would destroy Floyd. Prolly make him quit.

I think Floyd was a good fighter who was extremely popular in the US. He was so popular in the US that he got very favorable treatment by American refetharees and judges. In my opinion Hatton is a true all time great boxer and Floyd is not. Floyd was very good but falls short of all time great. I assume you are from the US and don't like my answer but you asked and that is my honest answer. I like your answer and even agree. I say Floyd is top 25 through pressure. I'm a softy and feel if i put him lower I will make many people in here cry.

I think Floyd was a good fighter who was extremely popular in the US. He was so popular in the US that he got very favorable treatment by American refetharees and judges. In my opinion Hatton is a true all time great boxer and Floyd is not. Floyd was very good but falls short of all time great. I assume you are from the US and don't like my answer but you asked and that is my honest answer.

Definitely Mayweather. I'm not even a Floyd fan (or Hatton for that matter) but it is indisputable that Floyd ranks above Hatton on an ATG list. Far above! I'm not even sure I would give Hatton an ATG nod

What kind of a question is this? There’s nothing you can compare Hatton’s to Floyd’s resume. The only thing Hatton can boast for himself is beating Tszyu and performing better than expected against past prime Castillo

Take everything into account, who you got higher in terms of being an ATG?I think Mayweather was so superior to Hatton that it shuld not even be debated. Mayweather beat him very easily and completely outclassed him. The few punches Hatton landed came from wrestling, mauling, and Hatton's famous holding and hitting. I don't consider Hatton an all time great fighter. I think he was a good fighter who was extremely popular in the UK. He was so popular in the UK that he got very favorable treatment by English referees and judges. Mayweather and Hatton both fought Pacquiao and look at the difference. In my opinion Mayweather is a true all time great boxer and Hatton is not.Hatton was very good but falls short of all time great. I assume you are from the UK and don't like my answer but you asked and that is my honest answer.

Troll thread

Ricky Hatton due to his WBU reign. Winner winner chicken lunch

Terrible Troll thread

Hatton and it's not a debate.

ATG lists change from person to person but one thing will be common in all, hatton is much lower than floyd, much lower!!

Ricky Hatton due to his WBU reign.

Is this a troll thread? It's got to be Floyd unless Hatton to p 25 ATG.

No argument can be made by any criteria that would put Hatton even close to Floyd, all time. Stupid bait threat is stupid.

Is this even a question? Floyd is light years ahead of hatton in terms of greatness