Pacquiao's ATG Status

He's top 50 I'd say. I think he's probably anywhere from 30-50 though I'd have him closer to 50 (slightly above Mayweather, Hopkins but probably slightly below Jones, Chavez), personally. Like a lot of modern fighters he hasn't had a dominant enough reign as the undisputed or clear #1 in a division. I don't value bouncing around in weight quite as much as others do I guess. We all have different criteria I guess so it's an inexact science but too many fans don't understand boxing history or haven't done research on things prior to their lives, especially when talking about their current favorite fighters.

Top 15 all-time for sure. Top 10 also likely.

He was already in the Top 20 after what he had done in the lower weights. He just exponentially added up to his ATG status after moving up and beating Dela Hoya, Hatton, Cotto, Margarito, etc. From flyweight to jr. middleweight. He's Top 5 if you're being generous. But he's already Top 10 for sure. He would be #1 ATG if he beats Spence for me. That would be a testament to his greatness. That's a big "IF" tho. He really has to be smart and efficient in that fight.

I was thinking about that today. I'd say somewhere in the top 25.

Broner Fight doesn't change anything. To me he is top 10 Can you line em up and break your top 10 down?

The same. Who doesn't beat their boner?

Broner Fight doesn't change anything. To me he is top 10

Ya but Roberto Duran won over Davey Moore was a big deal right? Broner is a 4 division champ. Who the hell is Davey Moore?

no change really, win over a bonehead is nothing.

Still between 10-15, the Broner fight doesn’t change much tbh. Pac’s legacy is already secured.

Top 5. Brone r level guys should be beating former flyweights with 70 fights under belt at 40 and if they don't you got to reward the ageing legends.