Would Canelo beat any top MW?

Yes... i think he beats saunders, Jacobs,GGG,Lemiuex..he is better then all of them

All except GGG

Rosado would beat the brakes off Canelo

People underestimating Jacobs, he is a big MW with power i think we would be tough for anyone in MW, including GGG. Right now i don't know how to rate Canelo if he moves up and actually fights one of the title holders at 160 then we will see.

Golovkin is the only one in the list that I wouldn't necessarily favour him over. He steals on the rest.

Canelo would beat everyone that GGG beat.

I think jacobs and quillin could beat him.

Cotto beat one of the best "middleweight" fighters on GGG resume, Geale, and beat him down easily. Yet Cotto has lost to Canelo and other top Jr Middleweights. Newsflash Middleweight is a hot garbage division. They are not better or more talented then the guys at 154, they are just bigger. 160 is the armpit division in boxing today. There is a reason why GGG is name dropping fighterd below and above 160 because that's where the better fighters are. To answer your question yes Canelo beats them he's more talented and skilled. Just like Cotto, Lara, Andrade, J-Will ect would. Better fighters and the money is at and around 154 why go up to 160 where even GGG admits the talent isn't there so he's calling out guys outside 160 for a reason. My thoughts exactly, I'd pick Cotto, Lara, Andrade, Williams and heck even the Charlo brothers to run through most of the division.

Cotto beat one of the best "middleweight" fighters on GGG resume, Geale, and beat him down easily. Yet Cotto has lost to Canelo and other top Jr Middleweights. Newsflash Middleweight is a hot garbage division. They are not better or more talented then the guys at 154, they are just bigger. 160 is the armpit division in boxing today. There is a reason why GGG is name dropping fighterd below and above 160 because that's where the better fighters are. To answer your question yes Canelo beats them he's more talented and skilled. Just like Cotto, Lara, Andrade, J-Will ect would. Better fighters and the money is at and around 154 why go up to 160 where even GGG admits the talent isn't there so he's calling out guys outside 160 for a reason. First: Geale sucks. Second: Geale was drained to 157. Third: Geale was headbutted badly before the punch that put him down. And NO the money is not at 154. The money is at 160 much more than 154. You can say 175 or 140 or 147 pays more than 160, but no way 154 has more money than 160. You are delusional to believe those LMW can campaign at MW like nothing.

Cotto beat one of the best "middleweight" fighters on GGG resume, Geale, and beat him down easily. Yet Cotto has lost to Canelo and other top Jr Middleweights. Newsflash Middleweight is a hot garbage division. They are not better or more talented then the guys at 154, they are just bigger. 160 is the armpit division in boxing today. There is a reason why GGG is name dropping fighterd below and above 160 because that's where the better fighters are. To answer your question yes Canelo beats them he's more talented and skilled. Just like Cotto, Lara, Andrade, J-Will ect would. Better fighters and the money is at and around 154 why go up to 160 where even GGG admits the talent isn't there so he's calling out guys outside 160 for a reason.

He didn't even fought one MW yet and some of you give him too many chances I think.

I think he has a good chance of beating anyone at Middleweight. The GGG fight is like 60-40 for Gennady to me

If he goes toe to toe with Lemieux he can be KO'ed

The other question is, would Canelo fight any of the top MWs @ the MW limit, or would he try that CW trash?

Anyone who can box has a decent chance of beating Canelo. I think Saunders boxes him in a pretty easy affair. Jacobs and Lemieux certainly have the power to stop him. He'd be the favourite because of name only, not because of merit. Realistically they're all competitive fights unless Canelo shows he's much better at 160. He's was consistently outboxed by Trout and Lara, and being outboxed in some rounds by a much smaller and older Cotto. He looks fantastic against come forward Brawler types like Angulo and Kirkland, but hasn't looked great otherwise. That being said, no-one is winning a decision over Canelo now. You can beat him, but you won't get the decision

Lemieux is basic to the core, BJS can't do anything with Canelo. Jacobs would be more challenging than those two but I can't see him beating Canelo. Only one on there is Golovkin.

I'd pick him over Lemieux, but I'd pick most people over Lemieux, Lee, Quillin. Not sure about the others.

From BJS, Jacobs, GGG, Lemieux, or any other top10 MW. Would he beat any of them? Would you put YOUR money on him? No you wouldn't. So **** off. I'd have him winning a close decision over Saunders (but that would be touch and go and I wouldn't be shocked if it went the other way) I think he'd win clear decisions over Lemieux and Jacobs and would lose to GGG.