Does Zab Judah make it to the Hall of Fame?

because the answer is pretty obvious. This isnt a genaro, diego corrales, naseem hamed situtation where there is an actual argument to be made for hall of fame. Do you think zab judah is greater than and had a better career than lets say danny red lopez? he damn sure had a better career then gatti

linares and broner are 3 division champs that sounds so good so they must get in

Ok. So judah's best win is the stoppage on Corey Spinks (both fights were good. Actually they were great fights and showed the rich talent both guys had.) After that is ****in Demarcus Corley, after that ****in Matthysee and most people thought he deserved to lose that. Then comes his winning a couple rounds against Danny G, the Tszyu fight which took his 0, his loss to Clottey which should've never went to the cards, screaming about Cotto cheating to his dad on the stool, his winning rounds 1,2,3 & 5 against floyd then just losing it, rolling on the ground and getting counted out against Khan and losing to a way past-it paulie malinaggi. Zab Judah isn't a Hall of Famer.

True. But we shouldn't just keep letting them in due to the low standards. I'm in total agreement. I hope they don't let Judah in because he doesn't belong there. It's bad enough as it is.

sure, as a janitor Pretty much Zab's only chance.

He lost all of his big fights. If he beat Cotto, Tszyu, Floyd, Khan or Garcia he would have a strong case.

The thing is, there are some ppl in the HOF that are just there because of their impact on boxing, not really how good they were. Hell, you have ppl who have nothing to do with pro boxing like Sly Stalone in the HOF just cuz of Rocky.

No, I don't think so his biggest win is against Cory Spinks. He beat Matthysse on the score cards but it could have gone either way. I thought Matthysse win that fight to be honest.

NO, Judah was good at one point but not great. Gatti got in because he was murdered, but if not he had a shot of getting in because of numerous wars, fight of the year awards, winning with cuts, swollen eyes, broken hands, surviving knockdowns and last but certainly not least his memorable come from behind knockout victories.

Zab was a champion multiple times and on top of that he was also a unified undisputed champion, not many fighters can say that. i feel like some of you guys are letting his most recent fights cloud your judgement.

Hell no. Talented guy but come on. People need to stop playing the Gatti card here too. Shouldn't be basing HoF eligibility on the outliers.

What do you guys think? He shouldn't but then his fellow New Yorker Riddick Bowe got in, so clearly he has a good shot for no valid reason.

I'd say yes. For his chicken dance alone!

Don't be an idiot, he's obviously better than rios but definitely not a hof. In your mind he is though because it makes Floyd beating him significant. I never once said gatti belongs in

Gatti doesn't belong........ True BUT Gatti doesn't belong either. Since when does "toughness" get you into the HOF???? That's BS, man. America is the biggest conartist country there is. Boxing should be ashamed for that one.

So if Brandon rios dies with in 10 years I guess he should be inducted Don't be an idiot, he's obviously better than rios but definitely not a hof. In your mind he is though because it makes Floyd beating him significant.

because the answer is pretty obvious. this isnt a genaro, diego corrales, naseem hamed situtation where there is an actual argument to be made for hall of fame. do you think zab judah is greater than and had a better career than lets say danny red lopez? zab is better than gatti and he got in.

Gatti got in because he's dead and was part of a action packed trilogy. Zab, thankfully, isn't dead nor does he have an epic fight. So if Brandon rios dies with in 10 years I guess he should be inducted

I think if they open a wing for guys with the best booty dew dance then he's in and there's a bust waiting for Amir Khan right next to him :)

Gatti got in because he's dead and was part of a action packed trilogy. Zab, thankfully, isn't dead nor does he have an epic fight.