If Judah beats Khan does that mean Khan is overrated?

I think if khan is as good as he and freddie tell us he is then this is a must win. Very good/elite fighters beat zab, its as simple as that. For khan to get to the next level this is an important fight, zab is past his best but still is a world champion calibre fighter and a step up for khan, he brings threats to the ring that khan has yet to experience in a fight, maybe he has in sparring but this will be a step up in regards to actual fights. I think khan will do it, simply because I believe he is destined to become a top 10 p4p fighter, and is already one of the best fighers in the world. Based on that belief, zab will be pulled out by his corner late in the fight. This will be khan's best performance to date in my opinion. BTW - Rome I believe you overrate peterson, he is a good, solid fighter, but there are plenty of fighters at 140 who can beat him imo. Alexander, khan, guerrero. I would favour all of them over peterson, I would have him and maidana or matysse as 50/50. I think Judah-Peterson, I agree with your interpretation on this fight, and I too would give peterson a great shot to pull this one off based on styles. I don't think I overrated Peterson,I said I believe he would beat most of the fighters at 140lb not that he is a shoe in..I really see a mentally tough fighter with skill,imo Devon is to robotic to beat Peterson..Bradley already showed Devon does not have an inside game and Peterson loves it inside..His body work is crazy as well..I think Khan and RG are 50/50 fights but I would bet on. Peterson on both fights...Peterson is a solid fighter with boxing I.Q.and aa real fighters mentality..

I think if khan is as good as he and freddie tell us he is then this is a must win. Very good/elite fighters beat zab, its as simple as that. For khan to get to the next level this is an important fight, zab is past his best but still is a world champion calibre fighter and a step up for khan, he brings threats to the ring that khan has yet to experience in a fight, maybe he has in sparring but this will be a step up in regards to actual fights. I think khan will do it, simply because I believe he is destined to become a top 10 p4p fighter, and is already one of the best fighers in the world. Based on that belief, zab will be pulled out by his corner late in the fight. This will be khan's best performance to date in my opinion. BTW - Rome I believe you overrate peterson, he is a good, solid fighter, but there are plenty of fighters at 140 who can beat him imo. Alexander, khan, guerrero. I would favour all of them over peterson, I would have him and maidana or matysse as 50/50. I think Judah-Peterson, I agree with your interpretation on this fight, and I too would give peterson a great shot to pull this one off based on styles.

If you look at the way Peterson fights he always fights to the level of comp he is fighting..He would get inside on Judah go to Judah's body and flat out make it a dog fight..Judah would be stop by Peterson imo..I also(and I said this before)would pick him against the majority of Jr WW fighting right now..Peterson is very underrated imo and just needs to be active and he will have a nice future.. I agree with the bold.

I disagree. Judah is not Judah from 6 years ago or so, he hasn't been relevant in years. Khan should not be losing to Judah. We'll have to agree to disagree then, I'm not looking at their credentials, I'm simply looking at both of their skill set, to say Khan isn't suppose to lose to Judah is overrating Khan. Yeah, maybe he's not in his physical prime but he still has alot left and is still improving on a few things.

The real question is when Amir beats Judah will people be saying Judah is shot?

Really? Actually it would be a good fight, but I think Zab would beat him. I think Zab is far more dangerous. Even if Zab would lose to Peterson I think Zab matches up with the other Jwws much better. Bradley would probably beat Zab, but even in this fight Zab would have a real shot. Zab still has real speed and power. And obviously experience fighting some of the best. If you look at the way Peterson fights he always fights to the level of comp he is fighting..He would get inside on Judah go to Judah's body and flat out make it a dog fight..Judah would be stop by Peterson imo..I also(and I said this before)would pick him against the majority of Jr WW fighting right now..Peterson is very underrated imo and just needs to be active and he will have a nice future..

It might depend how he wins if it is one sided or a blowout, it may appear he is overrated.

no Zab would deserve a lot of credit if he won clearly Khan is the best at 140 right now

Or does it mean Judah has finally found what he was missing mentally in fights, and now ready to get back in with elite competition? If Khan lose does that mean he is overrated and should stop mentioning elite fighters. What do you guys think? no..... fights do sometimes show us that there hardly is a sure winner...sometimes the outcome were truly unexpected...as upsets abound in the history of boxing....

I dont think so, at least not based on a loss to Judah. He might be overrated anyway.

no way...judah has had a solid career & fought the best win or lose....beating judah is a great accomplishment & there is no shame in losing to him.it may knock khan down a level but he is still young.

Maybe, it does depend on how wins. Because, if he wins cuz' of a robbery or a come from behind freaky KO, then it is what it is. But, if he straight up wins then yea it probably does mean that Khan is overrated. Because, really Judah has no business beating Khan. He just doesn't.

I think the safe bet in this fight is Khan by UD. Judah will have moments where he stuns Khan but Khan has proven that he has pretty decent survival skills. Judah will try his hardest but Khan is too fast, agile and young for him. I see Khan giving him a beating late in the fight, but Judah sees the final bell. I think thats how the fight will most likely play out too but i wouldnt be surprised if Judah kos him early.

I think the safe bet in this fight is Khan by UD. Judah will have moments where he stuns Khan but Khan has proven that he has pretty decent survival skills. Judah will try his hardest but Khan is too fast, agile and young for him. I see Khan giving him a beating late in the fight, but Judah sees the final bell.

Khan has already beaten some top fighters in his division maidana,kotelnik,maliggnagi so i wouldn't say he's overrated now so how would losing to a 2 division champ label him as so it just meant he got beat by the better guy that night and he still would have a future ahead of him as long as he doesn't get blitzed early

Ahh, Yeah. The fact that we are not looking at Judah as a serious thread says Khan's is underrated. Judah's power, speed and power are real and should be considered. Then comes the Chins factor, I believe both chins are vulnerable but IMO Khan has the weaker one. I see this as a 53-47 fight in favor of Khan. Judah CAN get any one flush. And if he does that to Khan, I want to see how Khan takes it, if he can take it, Judah is in trouble, because Judah does not have an iron chin either.

Well I think he is overrated now even before going into that fight...but he is only 24 years old...he also has a TON OF TALENT and he will only get better so lets say Zab Judah does beat him...he just work harder and try to bounce back from it...that is all he can do and you have IDIOTS posting stuff like "ZAB DOESN'T HAVE A CHANCE" that is just IGNORANT and it shows that they don't know sh!t about boxing and they are just acting like Amir Khan GROUPIES!

Ahh, Yeah. The fact that we are not looking at Judah as a serious thread says Khan's is underrated. Judah's power, speed and power are real and should be considered. Then comes the Chins factor, I believe both chins are vulnerable but IMO Khan has the weaker one.

Well Khan has already been knocked out in 1 round by Prescott. He's highly rated because of his win over Maidana. The Malignaggi win was good too. I'ma rhyme right now: A loss to Judah will definitely set him back badly, and he will need to stop mentioning Floyd Mayweather or even Tim Bradley. It would be disastrous if he once again loses in round one, with that, i'd say his career at the top level is done. Even a decision would put his career down the shitter, cause Judah is good but this is not the same one who beat Spinks, Corley and Witter. I'm rooting for Judah to break that glass chin, but with that said I think Amir Khan is gonna win. :D

Lol. Zab ain't some bum, he's a live dog, that's for sure. I don't think there is any shame in losing to a fighter of Zabs caliber. Khan had the option of fighting Morales later in the year. We should be thankful, he's making the tough fights. Outside of Bradley and Khan, I think Zab is easily the best jww right now. Can't wait to see this fight. Wish I could make it to Vegas to check it out. Peterson beats Zab imo..