Here's their list for the 100 best of 2009, please remember this came from the magazine, so things like the victories of Andre Ward, Lucian Bute, and Koki Kameda have not come into account yet. And don't ask where 51-55 is, it wasn't in the magazine, so I have no clue.
And this may be reaching, but I typed this up myself for all of you... and green k would be appreciated.
EDIT: This is based around who the top fighters are P4P in the sport right now, not who had the best year in boxing for 2009. As you might be able to tell, there was some confusion about this in the posts below.
But here it is,
RING MAGAZINE TOP 100 FIGHTERS OF 2009
100. Rogers Mtagwa
Junior Featherweight
99. Jorge Solis
Featherweight
98. Tavoris Cloud
IBF Light Heavyweight Titlist
97. Verno Phillips
Junior Middleweight
96. Isaac Hlatswayo
IBF Welterweight Titlist
95. Kendall Holt
Junior Welterweight
94. Rolando Reyes
Lightweight
93. Krzysztof Wlodarczyk
Cruiserweight
92. Daniel Santos
Junior Middleweight
91. Omar Nino
Junior Flyweight
90. Carlos Quintana
Welterweight
89. Ali Funeka
Lightweight
88. Wladimir Sidorenko
Bantamweight
87. Juan Urango
IBF Junior Welterweight Titlist
86. Eddie Chambers
Heavyweight
85. Sebastion Sylvester
IBF Middleweight Titlist
84. Sakio Bika
Super Middleweight
83. Roy Jones Jr.
Light Heavyweight
82. Kermit Cintron
Junior Middleweight
81. Librado Andrade
Super Middleweight
80. Cristobal Cruz
IBF Featherweight Titlist
79. Felix Sturm
WBA Middleweight Titlist
78. Giovanni Segura
WBA Junior Flyweight Titlist
77. Sergei Dzinziruk
Junior Middleweight
76. Yuriorkis Gamboa
WBA Featheweight Titlist
75. Steven Lueveno
Featherweight
74. Michael Katsidis
Lightweight
73. Nehomar Cermeno
Bantamweight
72. Edgar Sosa
WBO Junior Flyweight Titlist
71. Sergio Martinez
WBC Junior Middleweight Titlist
70. Takefumi Sakata
Flyweight
69. Raul Garcia
IBF Minimumweight Titlist
68. Andre Dirrell
Super Middleweight
67. Joel Casamayor
Lightweight
66. David Haye
WBA Heavyweight Titlist
65. Denis Boytsov
Heavyweight
64. Alexander Povetkin
Heavyweight
63. Anthony Mundine
Middleweight
62. Steve Molitor
Junior Featherweight
61. Jean Pascal
WBC Light Heavyweight Titlist
60. Alexander Munoz
Junior Bantamweight
59. Carl Froch
WBC Super Middleweight Titlist
58. Lucian Bute
IBF Super Middleweight Titlist
57. Omar Navarez
Flyweight
56. Ulises Solis
Junior Flyweight
50. Denkaosan Kaovichit
WBA Flyweight Titlist
49. Devon Alexander
WBC Junior Welterweight Titlist
48. Cory Spinks
IBF Junior Middleweight Titlist
47. Paul Malignaggi
Junior Welterweight
46. Juan Diaz
Junior Welterweight
45. Nate Campbell
Junior Welterweight
44. Hugo Cazares
WBA Junior Bantamweight Titlist
43. Jorge Linares
Junior Lightweight
42. Amir Khan
WBA Junior Welterweight Titlist
41. Pongsaklek Wonjongkam
Flyweight
40. Brian Viloria
IBF Junior Flyweight Titlist
39. Robert Guerrero
IBF Junior Lightweight Titlist
38. Anselmo Moreno
WBA Bantamweight Titlist
37. Andre Berto
WBC Welterweight Titlist
36. Poonsawat Kratingaenggym
WBA Junior Featherweight Titlist
35. Roman Gonzales
WBA Minimumweight Titlist
34. Steve Cunningham
Cruiserweight
33. Humberto Soto
Junior Lightweight
32. Joan Guzman
Junior Lightweight
31. Tomasz Adamek
World Cruiserweight Champion
30. Timothy Bradley
WBO Junior Welterweight Titlist
29. Juan Manuel Lopez
WBO Junior Featherweight Titlist
28. Juan Carlos Salgado
Junior Lightweight
27. Daisuke Naito
WBC Flyweight Titlist
26. Ricky Hatton
Junior Welterweight
25. Edwin Valero
WBC Lightweight Titlist
24. Joshua Clottey
Welterweight
23. Antonio Margarito
Welterweight
22. Vitali Klitschko
WBC Heavyweight Titlist
21. Fernando Montiel
Bantamweight
20. Wladimir Klitschko
World Heavyweight Champion
19. Mikkel Kessler
Super Middleweight
18. Glen Johnson
Light Heavyweight
17. Chris John
WBA Featherweight Titlist
16. Chad Dawson
IBF Light Heavyweight Titlist
15. Kelly Pavlik
World Middleweight Champion
14. Ivan Calderon
World Junior Flyweight Champion
13. Arthur Abraham
Super Middleweight
12. Hozumi Hasegawa
WBC Bantamweight Titlist
11. Paul Williams
Middleweight
10. Rafael Marquez
Featherweight
9. Israel Vazquez
Featherweight
8. Celestino Caballero
IBF/WBA Junior Feathweight Titlist
7. Miguel Cotto
Welterweight
6. Nonito Donaire
WBA Junior Bantamweight Titlist
5. Juan Manuel Marquez
World Lightweight Champion
4. Bernard Hopkins
Light Heavyweight
3. Sugar Shane Mosley
WBA Welterweight Titlist
2. Floyd Mayweather
Welterweight
1. Manny Pacquiao
World Junior Welterweight Champion / WBO Welterweight Titlist
Let the debate begin.
Definitely because it wouldn't make any sense at all. Just to see Pavlik at #15 made me understand.
Yeah, the list would be completely different if it was actually a top fighters of 09 and they went by what happened in 09. It would be something like:
1. Pacquiao
2. V. Klitschko
3. Ward
4. Dawson
5. Bute
etc.
You got a point but not enough to be at #6.
I don't think he should be there either, just that his last fight shouldn't drop him and IMO he isn't far from where he should be (around 8-10).
Dawson should be in front of him because even though he doesn't have a win as Darchinyan, Adamek, Tarver (2x), and Johnson (2x), put him over the top.
It's less of a Top 100 Fighters of 2009 and more of a Top 100 Fighters P4P.
Definitely because it wouldn't make any sense at all. Just to see Pavlik at #15 made me understand.
But Concepcion missed weight by 4.5 pounds, it was a super bantamweight fighting a super flyweight. Donaire would hit him solid and he'd walk right through it and throw shots that were landing harder because of the advantage.
If Arce had Concepcion wincing with every single shot, I find it hard to believe Donaire was that far behind in the power department.
On a P4P level, Donaire's Darchinyan win was better and more impressive than either of their wins. The Martinez win was solid too.
You got a point but not enough to be at #6.
yea i like both caballero and donaire but your right dude. IMO donaire's last fight should have been a step back... Caballero had that nasty decision in panama 2 fights ago and chris john looked bad at the last round against rocky but chris john was dominant the whole fight and chris john is still undefeated!!!! (yes i know donaires first loss he was young or whatever) but bradley dawson and john >>> Donaire Caballero
But Concepcion missed weight by 4.5 pounds, it was a super bantamweight fighting a super flyweight. Donaire would hit him solid and he'd walk right through it and throw shots that were landing harder because of the advantage.
If Arce had Concepcion wincing with every single shot, I find it hard to believe Donaire was that far behind in the power department.
On a P4P level, Donaire's Darchinyan win was better and more impressive than either of their wins. The Martinez win was solid too.
This list is garbage... I am Donaire fan but how come he is ranked so high? Anf Viloria too far despite of that sensational KO and a UD?.. The Ring must be joking... Mayweather and Hopkins both inactive and fought so boring yet they rank so high...
yea i like both caballero and donaire but your right dude. IMO donaire's last fight should have been a step back... Caballero had that nasty decision in panama 2 fights ago and chris john looked bad at the last round against rocky but chris john was dominant the whole fight and chris john is still undefeated!!!! (yes i know donaires first loss he was young or whatever) but bradley dawson and john >>> Donaire Caballero
You got the point.
Bradley, Dawson>>>Donaire, Caballero
Chris John #17? WTF?
yea i like both caballero and donaire but your right dude. IMO donaire's last fight should have been a step back... Caballero had that nasty decision in panama 2 fights ago and chris john looked bad at the last round against rocky but chris john was dominant the whole fight and chris john is still undefeated!!!! (yes i know donaires first loss he was young or whatever) but bradley dawson and john >>> Donaire Caballero
It really isnt and Pavlik is ranked way too high if they are basing it on 2009. Pavlik did very little in 2009.
Though that might explain the list better if they WEREN'T going on just 2009, but overall who's the cream of the crop in the sport.
Taken from the Ring Magazine's rankings
Antonio Margarito
Last Year's Rating: 6
Status Report: Margarito's 17-point tumble is attributable in the main not to his shocking loss to Sugar Shane Mosley - there's no dishonor there - or to his subsequent inactivity. They work against him, but not as much as the revelation that his wraps were loaded going into the Mosley fight, as well as the very reasonable possibility that they were similarly doctored in all of his big wins. Can he fight? Absolutely, we just aren't sure how well.
Donaire at #6? Who has he actually fought aside from Darchinyan to deserve that spot?
he fought at jr bantamweight against a guy that weighed in at jr featherweight officially and was a jr. lightweight or lightweight by fight night and still won.
There are so many things wrong with this list it is tough to know where to start. I guess we all have a favorite fighter or two - writers included - they must have rated their favorites really high. No way objective - Hatton, Margarito, there are some real bad rankings there.