Who is Higher ATG List? Mosley or Mayweather?

You're an idiot, SSM isn't even an ATG But Calzaghe is? WTF? hahahahahaha Of course he is, but Floyd is the best to lace them up this era. Simple as that.

I am going with Mosley, but Mayweather has probably accomplished more with holding titles in more divisions, etc.

PBF takes this one but no discrespecting Mosley, he is still an awesome fighter and to have come from defeat to being a champion takes some doing

You're an idiot, SSM isn't even an ATG Thats Crazy, the guy is a Legend! I think he pips Floyd in the ATG list guys a throwback

they both are great but mosley has better wins so mosley takes it. don't be confused by all that 5 weight division champ fluff. mosley could have killed gatti at 140 too if he felt like wasting everyone's time.

Mr boat buyer has accomplished more.

The answer will be obvious after they fight. If they ever do. Til then, I would have to say Mosley because he can recover from defeats and come back to become a champion. As for Mayweather, one can't deny his greatness but he ducks fights and is afraid of losing because he is unsure of being able to rebound as well as Mosley and others have.

A win over oscar dela hoya in his prime is nice if you dont admit to taking balco for those fights or did you forget that. Those victories or tainted so there will always be an asteric by those wins. and my questions was a slick boxer and for that matter any boxer, especially a boxer with speed, i recall shane mosley jumping from 135 to 147 without fighting zab judah

I do have a tendency to attack Floyd, I should lay off it. I think I do it because of people unjust-fully attacking Calzaghe. So, I guess I shouldn't be like that. you can attack floyd, i dont care, its what people do, but when people get personal, i tend to put them on ignore. Trust me, im nobody on this board, but it makes this place better when people can stick to attacking the position and not the person. We are all guilty to some extent, but when you keep it to a minimum, it makes this place more desirable with healthy argument. by getting personal i mean users who insult other users, to me, either take that shit to the thunderdome or leave that shit alone.

Mayweather takes this

U mean, every week. Shame on u. :smashfrea you been here as long as me, thus you know, this thread constantly pops up, looking at mosleys resume, he fought alot of good fighters, but mayweather has far more quality wins. Mayweathers flaws were at welter when it came to competition, especially since at 140, the only fighter to visibly call him out was vivian harris. Even then, he solved that by fighting hatton, even if you want to say "he fought hatton at 147" hatton could have avoided that by fighting him at 140 instead of turning him down, twice. at 147, without a doubt its mosley, but other than that, objectively, mayweather is higher.

Not you, i dont agree with some of what you say, but people i put on ignore are people who strawman their way through every argument and use alot of personal insult/ad-hom attacks. i just dont have time to waste on that shit. I do have a tendency to attack Floyd, I should lay off it. I think I do it because of people unjust-fully attack Calzaghe(those same users happen to be floyd fans, but its quite childish of me to attack them back). So, I guess I shouldn't be like that.

Mosley for me.

All you kids keep talking about shane fought the best in his division but who did he beat nodody except margacheato. I dont care who you fight unless you beat them, cuz i can play michael jordan tomorrow but im not great unless i beat him. Mosley has never fought a boxer let alone a slick boxer check his resume. How the hell did shane get outboxed by a brawler (cotto) and thensay he can beat a pure boxer? So beating Oscar De La Hoya in his prime, isn't an accomplishment, not only once but twice?

Me or the idiot who I responded to? Because I already explained I didn't like floyd but I haven't discredit him like other users on here. He is an atg. Not you, i dont agree with some of what you say, but people i put on ignore are people who strawman their way through every argument and use alot of personal insult/ad-hom attacks. i just dont have time to waste on that shit.

Why the fuk does this stupid question get asked every year? U mean, every week. Shame on u. :smashfrea

honestly, every post from that guy gets on my nerves, i must now add his ass to my ignore list. my ignore list is getting exceptionally long. Me or the idiot who I responded to? Because I already explained I didn't like floyd but I haven't discredit him like other users on here. He is an atg.

Why is it garbage to beat the best in your weight division and to beat 6-8 former world champions and to defend the belt 21 times without getting beat? Is it because he is white and exciting and you're a racist crackhead poster and no wonder why you have red karma, and here comes more red karma racist bitch. honestly, every post from that guy gets on my nerves, i must now add his ass to my ignore list. my ignore list is getting exceptionally long.

All you kids keep talking about shane fought the best in his division but who did he beat nodody except margacheato. I dont care who you fight unless you beat them, cuz i can play michael jordan tomorrow but im not great unless i beat him. Mosley has never fought a boxer let alone a slick boxer check his resume. How the hell did shane get outboxed by a brawler (cotto) and thensay he can beat a pure boxer?

Floyd is one of the greatest PFP of all time. Mosley had an okay career, but he's always been pretty overrated. Calzaghe is garbage. Why is it garbage to beat the best in your weight division and to beat 6-8 former world champions and to defend the belt 21 times without getting beat? Is it because he is white and exciting and you're a racist crackhead poster and no wonder why you have red karma, and here comes more red karma racist bitch.