Was Oscar The Best Fighter At 154, when Floyd fought him?

Oscar knocked out Mayorga in dominating fashion, in a fashion far worse than anyone had ever done before.Now that the dust has settled from the Mayweather/Delahoya spectacle, was Floyd really moving up to fight the best fighter at 154? Mayorga had just handily beaten Piccirillo for the WBC strap, a fighter who had long been competitive at the weight, and Oscar then went on to slap Mayorga silly to set up the Golden vs Pretty Boy match-up. Others will argue Karmazin was the best at that weight, or Spinks (I'm certain Spinks was making a move up to 160 though) What do you think? Considering 154 was shit when they fought, saying Yes doesn't make Floyd look that much better. But if thats the answer you're looking for, then Yes I guess.

I think he was ranked at the top of the division, but it may have been Karmazin or Spinks. I don't remember when those 2 fought for the IBF belt. Karmazin had beaten Ouma for the top spot in that division tho, but DLH beatin Mayo mighta vaulted him ahead.

It was either Oscar, Spinks, or Forrest...

Oscar knocked out Mayorga in dominating fashion, in a fashion far worse than anyone had ever done before.Now that the dust has settled from the Mayweather/Delahoya spectacle, was Floyd really moving up to fight the best fighter at 154? Mayorga had just handily beaten Piccirillo for the WBC strap, a fighter who had long been competitive at the weight, and Oscar then went on to slap Mayorga silly to set up the Golden vs Pretty Boy match-up. Others will argue Karmazin was the best at that weight, or Spinks (I'm certain Spinks was making a move up to 160 though) What do you think? I dont know, but even if he was, Oscar was only a big fish in a small pond and Floyd only beat him by 1 round on 1 scorecard. Personally I think Spinks or Karmazin would be far more dangerous to Floyd than Oscar, although it is possible that Oscar was the best fighter at 154 overall.

He moved up to fight OSCAR , it was money prestige and something Floyd had been trying to do for a very long time , OSCAR called the shots on everything and made Floyd earn the fight by winning linear WW title to get the fight , then Floyd had to give him nearly 16 pounds on the night of the fight . Its was nothing to do with the best at 154 it was about fighting the biggest name in boxing , just like Manny who fought Oscar for very the same reason . good post, green k for you

Yea thats what i thought. They also have Vernon Forrest as the #1 SMW, do you really think he beats Paul Williams? "" Shane Mosley "" WW, just older and more ring worn since his loss to Cotto. "" Vlad Klit "" HW, do you think he beats Vitali? " Bernard Hopkins "" LHW "" Chad Dawson? " Humberto Soto "" SFW, WTF?????? " Vasquez JFW "" Caballero? etc etc etc

He was ranked #1 JMW by The Ring. Yea thats what i thought.

Hard to say, it was a year since the Mayorga fight, and more than a year and a half before that without any fights at all for Oscar. He was 9 years past his peak at #1 p4p, there were certainly more challenging and active fights at 154 to be made. But hey, people are arguing that most 147 lbers are too big for Floyd, so I guess the odds of him fighting a legit 154 lber are 0 and none.