If Taylor beats Froch p4p top 10?

Froch is garbage and beating him proves nothing. If Taylor can't beat Froch, he might as well retire. Taylor is the biggest waste of talent in boxing today. He has ability, but he's nowhere near as good as he should be.

Damn am i the only one who is maybe "overrating" taylor? Maybe i am doing it so when Roy beats TAylor, he can get back on top LMAO Well one thing about this is that JT was not and probably will not ever be on the level of Roy Jones Jr. so that argument can't hold here. Even at this stage in his game, being WELL passed his prime, I still feel, as do many, that he beats JT who is indeed IN his prime. Chew on that thought for a minute.

He was winning the fight until he got KOed, and the second fight, while he lost, was close. I feel Taylor did much better in the 2nd fight.. In the 1st fight I feel the Fix was in ...From round 3 till the KO.. those were all Pavlik rounds .. I am not alone in saying that..

j/k lol

Damn am i the only one who is maybe "overrating" taylor? Maybe i am doing it so when Roy beats TAylor, he can get back on top LMAO

Being undefeated at 140 with wins over a way past his prime Kostya, vs being unified Middle weight champ and beating a close to prime Hopkins and wright hmmm.... Ricky beat down his opponents and yes, even Kostya no matter how much credit you DON'T wanna give him for that win when, literally, NOBODY gave him a chance in that fight. You can argue Taylor lost all 3 of those fights with Hop and Winky especially, so stop. The man has had a great career so far, but his losses have taken him back a step, nothing wrong with that and I see him regaining his stature in the near future starting with Froch. Just not top 10 P4P status.

Being undefeated at 140 with wins over a way past his prime Kostya, vs being unified Middle weight champ and beating a close to prime Hopkins and wright hmmm....

ok Roger yomama, tell me why losing lopsided fight to floyd and walking down a dude who hits lighter than Calz shouls get you into p4p 10? Cause he's been undefeated at 140lbs for 10 years. That alone, puts him ahead of JT.

If Taylor beats Froch he might get in the top 20 but not 10.

ok Roger yomama, tell me why losing lopsided fight to floyd and walking down a dude who hits lighter than Calz shouls get you into p4p 10?

But those 2 loses were close, and Froch is an undefeated champ. Also, hatton did nothing but is in the P4P, and who the fuk is P williams, and what has he done? beat margarita?? Dawson nearly lost to an old man, or should i say lost to an old man? I think some of you guys underestimate a win over Froch Pavlik knocked him out cold , what's close about that?

so would you put Dawson of hatton ahead of Taylor if he beats froch?

But those 2 loses were close, and Froch is an undefeated champ. Also, hatton did nothing but is in the P4P, and who the fuk is P williams, and what has he done? beat margarita?? Dawson nearly lost to an old man, or should i say lost to an old man? I think some of you guys underestimate a win over Froch 2 losses where close? Do you even remember Pav/Taylor 1 ?? Even the second fight wasn't that close. He beats Lacy, gee, who hasn't anymore? Now we get to Froch...you put top 10 p4p stock in Carl Froch???? See where I'm getting at. I was trying to be fair to Jermain and give him his due because he has fought some great opposition, but come on, a Froch defeat DOES NOT carry enough power to get him in the top 10. If he beats Kessler, then we can talk.

He was winning the fight until he got KOed, and the second fight, while he lost, was close.

Taylor would have to beat Bute or Kessler for me to put him Top10

no,not a chance.

But those 2 loses were close, and Froch is an undefeated champ. Also, hatton did nothing but is in the P4P, and who the fuk is P williams, and what has he done? beat margarita?? Dawson nearly lost to an old man, or should i say lost to an old man? I think some of you guys underestimate a win over Froch

So 2 wins in his last 4 fights, both against mediocre opposition, puts him in the top 10 fighters in the sport? Naaaaaah.

Too early, I don't think he overtakes a guy in the top 10 as it stands right now. He HAS had a hell of a career so far in the 2 fights with Hop, Winky and 2 with Pav but I still feel people won't let him slide by the likes of Hatton and Williams - just yet. Time will tell though.