Pacman or Calzaghe

manny could have had the year off and still get fighter of the year over calzaghe pacman>>>>calzahge

Joe has been a dominant fighter for well over a decade. hopkins , eubank , jones , lacy , kessler...... we can all agree those are his top 5 wins. 4 of those fights barely were 2-3 years ago. hardly being dominant for a decade. he won his belt 11 years ago. he didn't fight another champion for 9 years. not until lacy in 2006 did he fight another beltholder. that's not being dominant. he was good for a long time but NOT dominant 'til recently.

manny could have had the year off and still get fighter of the year over calzaghe

I rest my case. You can slice through anyones resume like that you seem to be comparing him to DLH but DLH which is obviously a flawed comparison from the get go. Joe has been a dominant fighter for well over a decade.

LOL. Eubank was 31, Kessler 28, Lacy 28. Reid Late 20's, Bika (yes Bika) Late 20's, Omar Sheika late 20's, Byron Mitchell-30, Charles Brewer-33, Richie Woodhall-32 Joe Calzaghe's resume is good, not great, anyway you slice it. I rest my case.

calzaghes not great He is actually. A guy who cleans out a division and come to a point when he has no obvious guy to fight despite holding all the aces is pretty special.

Why's everyone trying to discredit Calzaghe? I'm not doubting Pac-man had a better year, but you guys act as if Calzaghe had never accomplished anything. Remember, Calzaghe is aging to, he's what, 35-36 years old? That's about how old DLH is and Calzaghe is still a great fighter. how many fighters in their 40's has dlh faced? Calzaghe has accomplished nothing in my eyes. The only legit victory for him is still out there(Dawson) but he is choosing to retire. He hasn't a single great win in his career.

calzaghes not great Why so????

Really. give me Calzaghe's 5 best wins with the age of the fighters(at the time that he fought them) next to their names. LOL. Eubank was 31, Kessler 28, Lacy 28. Reid Late 20's, Bika (yes Bika) Late 20's, Omar Sheika late 20's, Byron Mitchell-30, Charles Brewer-33, Richie Woodhall-32 Joe Calzaghe's resume is good, not great, anyway you slice it.

Why's everyone trying to discredit Calzaghe? I'm not doubting Pac-man had a better year, but you guys act as if Calzaghe had never accomplished anything. Remember, Calzaghe is aging to, he's what, 35-36 years old? That's about how old DLH is and Calzaghe is still a great fighter. calzaghes not great

Why's everyone trying to discredit Calzaghe? I'm not doubting Pac-man had a better year, but you guys act as if Calzaghe had never accomplished anything. Remember, Calzaghe is aging to, he's what, 35-36 years old? That's about how old DLH is and Calzaghe is still a great fighter.

Calzaghe vs. Marquez' 2008 should be the better question. :D

pac .

Pac easily.

calzaghe is not a fraud and deserves the spotlight he's on calzaghe's a fraud, get off his nuts

calzaghe is not a fraud and deserves the spotlight he's on Really. give me Calzaghe's 5 best wins with the age of the fighters(at the time that he fought them) next to their names.

pac no question. Diaz, JMM, DLH. calz beat a 39 year old Roy and a 43 year old Hops.

bump .

so its official, pacman is greater than calzaghe could ever be and calzaghe is a fraud, got cha

definitely pacman