Time to recognise the serious posters on boxingscene, just nominate anybody you think should be included in the list. The categories that will be taken into account when finalising the list are:
-Impartiality
-Boxing Knowledge
-Ability to argue a point (without being childish)
-Writing Style
List will be published in two days. The top 9 will all receive a gift marking their achievement and number 1 will receive 10k!
You cannot nominate yourself.
Seriously I'm surprise no one mentioned jabsRstiff :D. He's an old schooler way back the old hbo forum. For me he's classic when it comes to boxing info. Though it's been a long time since he posted here. Checking out his posts.
jabsRstiff ftw. :boxing:
And that is why I cannot be considered for a list like this, LOL.
Incidentally, a cruel twist of fate that precipitated this cock-up - Couple of nights ago, I downloaded the Qawi Vs Holyfield fights in 3 parts, and on the final one, I got asked for a password :(
Which I don't know and could not find :(
How little I knew that would come back to haunt me :(
Man that would suck. Password on the final one? As long as you got the full first fight in, that was a good one.
Scott and Thread Stealer have really got to be right up there.
If it is purely based on knowledge I think it comes down to these two guys and Silencers and TheMachine.
You know, those guys are the reason i still come here because when i read their posts i feel like i know nothing, which is a good thing, because i can then expand my knowledge instantaneously, those guys are a credit to the board.
Sadly, my knowledge is mostly between the 126-160lb division of the last 15 years, so for some of these guys, like silencers, who are near the same age is me, i find it amazing they know so much.
Scott and Thread Stealer have really got to be right up there.
If it is purely based on knowledge I think it comes down to these two guys and Silencers and TheMachine.
Silencers is right about 90% of the time. Well.., when I say right, I mean I agree 90% of the time.
If someone were tabulating this, he would seem to be the winner by far. A worthy choice too.
Also,
Scott90210
Eaner
Neils
Silencer (most of his statements are impossible to argue lol)
If that is supposed to be me, muchas gracias. You combined my first name with my favorite zip code and TV show. :D
:nono:
...............................
Outside of the use of smilies, can you offer any kind of refutation to that pick? And no, you can't use that I say unfavorable things about your favorite fighters as a reason.
BTW, my list is something like:
Yogi
DWiens
TheManchine
BozoNoNo (Where is he?)
Drew Woodside
RunwithKnives
BatTheMan
No order, but here's ten:
1. Wmute
2. Thread Stealer
3. The Bringer
4. Slicksouthpaw16
5. Wpink11 (dude doesn't post in NSB and his shit is long, but he makes really good points)
6. Dwiens
7. Sliencers
8. The Machine
9. Bat the Man
10. Dios Diomincos.
Hard list, to make that top 10. Outside are Danc, Hyperion, and probably a lot of other people I'm forgetting.
edit: Can't believe I ****ing forgot Jab(numbers) and Boof. I loved arguing with Boof. He would disagree, but he'd put up a good challenge.