Who wins right now, Roy Jones or Jermain Taylor?

Amazing how much things have changed in the 4 1/2 months since this poll. Surely Roy wouldn't win this poll today.

Whoever voted Jones is an idiot. Taylor would smash him

Roy Jones Jr.

...............................

I am going with Taylor by UD. He is still younger & now hungrier. Even though he is not a big puncher he can still hit, so I wouldn't be surprised if he wobbled Roy.

Obviously you're a smart fan that sees through the lack of significance of the win. Tito is a name but he's a shell of what he was and maybe he was a bit overrated too. Yeah, it doesn't mean much at all at this point, it wouldn't have meant much in 2001 either.

Tough to say, Taylor would go all out, depends how roy handles the pressure.. if i had to i would pick roy by ud.

Taylor beats Roy IMO.

Taylor would probably take a UD. Still Roy Jones is way to big for this middleweight, but I bet Roy would fight him.

from the trinidad fight and remember he has a hurt left too The Trinidad win doesn't mean much to me honestly.

Fair enough, so why are so many saying Cal is avoiding Pavlik and is scared of Pav when Taylor had him badly hurt in the first fight. If JT dropped and hurt Pav and Cal hits harder....you do the math. they are called idiots my friend. calzaghe would embaress pavlik,even some pavlik fans would agree.

I'm not sure, it depends on how much Jones has left. from the trinidad fight and remember he has a hurt left too

I'm not sure, it depends on how much Jones has left.

Ok here's the problem. Alot of you guys have said the way to beat RJJ is to make him fear your power and Cal doesnt have the power to scare Jones blah blah blah. But JT does have power and if he hit Roy clean he would hurt him and maybe drop him. I think if they fought and JT went after him Roy would go into the shell like he did against Tarver and look to just survive. Taylor in 12 calzaghe hits harder than taylor

RJJ by KO!

Roy UD. He always holds his lead hand low, so there's space for Taylor to connect wit his right hand, but that's the only danger for Roy I'd see in this fight. Won't go so far as to say he could own Taylor at this point, but he'd win.

Yeah Roy would win, bigger, faster, more powerful, more skilled.