Now That U Look At It Quintana>>margarito Paul Williams

I see them all at the same level.It's cotto pbf and everyone else

I think williams just had an off night and was out of shape.

And if he doesn't KO him? I'm just saying, Margarito has KO'd one dude in the top 10. Quintana is clearly in the top 10. So, I just don't think Margarito is likely to KO him. Since I think Quintana is a little bit more technically sound I think he pulls out a decision. IMO I just think he'll eventually catch him.

Why would it mean he's better than Margarito? I remember when Mayorga fought De La Hoya he was saying he would win cuz he beat Forrest who beat Mosley who beat DLH, and look how that ended up. That's not the way boxing works dude. yeah thats ridiculous and i really dont like how people think this has raised cottos stock. anyone can think theyre the greatest with that line of thinking... cotto beat quintana who beat paul williams who beat margarito who beat joshua clottey who beat diego corrales who beat castillo who beat PBF. garbage.

By this I mean knock him out.And if he doesn't KO him? I'm just saying, Margarito has KO'd one dude in the top 10. Quintana is clearly in the top 10. So, I just don't think Margarito is likely to KO him. Since I think Quintana is a little bit more technically sound I think he pulls out a decision.

Funny how you turn every thread into something about Floyd.:nonono: Quintana is a better boxer than Margarito and Williams, but he lacks the chin, activity and power of Margarito and the chin and activity of Williams. Because of that M and W would beat some fighters that Q couldn't. Funny how you cant do anything but comment on my post because they leave you exposed in your own mind as the hater you are. Get of my nuts & Floyds. Pleease!

Quintana is a great boxer but he also likes to get in close and mix it up once in a while. No question Quintana has better skills but thru the course of a 12 round fight I think Margarito catches him. By this I mean knock him out.

So are you saying that Margarito is going to hit Quintana more often or that he's going to hurt Quintana? Quintana is a great boxer but he also likes to get in close and mix it up once in a while. No question Quintana has better skills but thru the course of a 12 round fight I think Margarito catches him.

Williams and Margarito do have similar styles. Only difference is Margarito isn't a feather fisted lop. So are you saying that Margarito is going to hit Quintana more often or that he's going to hurt Quintana?

Funny how you turn every thread into something about Floyd.:nonono: Quintana is a better boxer than Margarito and Williams, but he lacks the chin, activity and power of Margarito and the chin and activity of Williams. Because of that M and W would beat some fighters that Q couldn't.Who have Margarito and Williams beaten that Quintana couldn't? Williams' best win is against Margarito. Clearly you don't think Quintana could beat Margarito, but I think that's a pick'em fight or Quintana is a slight favorite. Margarito's best win is against Cintron and then probably Clottey. Again, Quintana is right in the mix with both of those guys. Really the problem to me is that these other top 10 welterweights haven't fought each other. At some point, it needs to get passed the point where guys are just sitting around waiting for either Mayweather or Cotto to fight them. They need to go out and beat the rest of the top 10 welterweights. THAT is why Floyd fans get excited to see an overhyped guy lose. Because the facts are that Margarito, Williams and Quintana all have only 1 or 2 top 10 guys on their resume, which makes them roughly equal.

I think Quintana is better than Margarito. Williams and Margarito have very similar styles and make a lot of the same mistakes. Quintana could actually make a pretty big name for himself if he wins a rematch against Williams and then defends successfully against the Margarito-Cintron loser. I think that alone might be enough to land him a Cotto fight. Williams and Margarito do have similar styles. Only difference is Margarito isn't a feather fisted lop.

Quintana is definitely better than both those guys. Margarito & Williams have been exposed but at least Williams took his loss like a man. It just goes to show how low the Floyd haters will go. They will try to hype anyone just to discredit the great ring accomplishments of Floyd. Funny how you turn every thread into something about Floyd.:nonono: Quintana is a better boxer than Margarito and Williams, but he lacks the chin, activity and power of Margarito and the chin and activity of Williams. Because of that M and W would beat some fighters that Q couldn't.

Quintana is definitely better than both those guys. Margarito & Williams have been exposed but at least Williams took his loss like a man. It just goes to show how low the Floyd haters will go. They will try to hype anyone just to discredit the great ring accomplishments of Floyd.

Quintana is a good southpaw, he will give anyone problems whos an orthodox fighter but cotto is both orthodox and southpaw!!!Cotto is also better than most of the other welterweights that Quintana either has fought or might fight.

I think Quintana is better than Margarito. Williams and Margarito have very similar styles and make a lot of the same mistakes. Quintana could actually make a pretty big name for himself if he wins a rematch against Williams and then defends successfully against the Margarito-Cintron loser. I think that alone might be enough to land him a Cotto fight.

You can definitely argue this although I see Margarito coming on late and beating Quintana in a close fight.

Why would it mean he's better than Margarito? I remember when Mayorga fought De La Hoya he was saying he would win cuz he beat Forrest who beat Mosley who beat DLH, and look how that ended up. That's not the way boxing works dude. Except for the fact that Mayorga fights like he's a 5th grader in a school playground, and relies entirely on landing a wild bomb.

Margarito beats Cintron and Quintana in my opinion.

I think it just shows how tough the 147lb division is right now..there are no easy fights in that division. Quintana, Williams and Margarito are all great fighters but they are not as good as PBF and Cotto or even Shane. Everyone was riding Williams becuase of his win over Margarito, but Margarito was basically made his name when he beat Cintron another great 147lbs fighter. But not in the same class as PBF, Cotto or Shane.

no i don't think he is way better