Floyd still at number 1 naturally.
I was concerned that Hatton would be dropped from the top ten, but really he hasn't moved. Which I think is justified. He moved up in weight against the number one and made a fight of it for six rounds.
Great stuff.
Yep they have, the list is valid from 9th Dec, or Sunday.
Well with Hopkins 2-2 in his last 4 fights and Winky 1-1-1 in his last three still being on there, I don't see why Ricky wouldn't. How does losing to #1 drop you at all? I mean it went 10 rounds, not 1.
I don't think Pacquiao's performance against Barrera looked like the performance of the P4P number two.
i understand, but floyds last couple performances were looked at in the same vain and he wasnt removed, i dont think the same should happen to manny, id be a hypocrite if i said otherwise.
TBH Hatton does not deserve 8th never fought a good fighter who isnt over the hill except Floyd and he got destroyed.
Destroyed is what happened to Arturo Gatti. Hatton wasn't destroyed.
TBH Hatton does not deserve 8th never fought a good fighter who isnt over the hill except Floyd and he got destroyed.
Hey you must be the one guy who picked Hatton to beat Tszyu based on Tszyu being past it! You're like a mini celebrity!
Or did you not even watch that fight and you're just regurgitating the opinions of others? Hmmm...
I'd probably pick Hopkins to beat Pavlik right now, but I don't know. Hopkins hasn't shown me anything lately to make me think he can beat a relentless puncher like Pavlik, much less Calzaghe
I would agree that Hopkins would beat Pavlik. And in fairness Hopkins dropped out of the rankings after the second loss to Taylor only to spring right back up there when he moved to light heavy and beat Tarver. My point being that a p4p guy can be beaten by a fighter and still be above them in the p4p rankings depending on the circumstances. Taylor beat Hopkins but do you really think that Taylor could have beaten Tarver? Do you think that Hopkins would have been kayoed by Pavlik?
It's a funny thing the p4p rankings.
I'm surprised they have JMM and Hopkins in front of Calzaghe. It's good of The Ring to recognize Hatton's effort and not drop him.
Yeah Floyd beat him cleanly, but losing to number 1 doesn't mean you suddenly got worse. We need to credit guys for tyaking the biog fights, not lpunish them.
at worst; I can't see how anyone could rate Pacquiao above him to be honest. Hopkins that high after such a weak run is a joke and spoils the entire list
Thank you. I think Pac-Joe is close but it is close possibly even tied.
no one should be overtaking pacman at number 2.
I don't think Pacquiao's performance against Barrera looked like the performance of the P4P number two.
Calzaghe should be 3 right now.
at worst; I can't see how anyone could rate Pacquiao above him to be honest. Hopkins that high after such a weak run is a joke and spoils the entire list
WOW, just WOW.:pat:
did you not understand my post? I said I'd pick Hopkins based on his past accomplishments, but I wasn't confident at all in it and would wait til he gets closer to fighting to pick one way or another against Calzaghe OR Pavlik. Slow?
I'd probably pick Hopkins to beat Pavlik right now, but I don't know. Hopkins hasn't shown me anything lately to make me think he can beat a relentless puncher like Pavlik, much less Calzaghe
WOW, just WOW.:pat:
To answer a couple people in one post:
1) Floyd is everyone's #1, not just The Ring's. This is the same magazine that had Hopkins ranked ahead of Roy on the list for beating Trinidad, despite Roy rolling over his opposition and looking good doing it. Just because The Ring picks the guy EVERYONE picks doesn't mean they are intelligent at that magazine. It means they have no choice because if they could have another guy as #1, believe me, they would.
2) No, I don't think any of the main writers, contributors to the Ring have anything worthwhile to say. Nigel Collins is a complete moron and he's in charge over there. I think Bert Sugar runs the whole thing, and we all know how retarded that "boxing historian" is. Now that Oscar owns it, I expect it to get a lot worse. I stopped buying the fuckin thing 2 years ago.
Just as an aside, who wins out of Pavlik and Hopkins?
I'd probably pick Hopkins to beat Pavlik right now, but I don't know. Hopkins hasn't shown me anything lately to make me think he can beat a relentless puncher like Pavlik, much less Calzaghe