Extended p4p List

How can you possibly have Winky at 1 and Taylor at 11??? They just drew, and recently, JT has the far bigger wins (2 over Hop) Winky beat a bloated Mosley at 154 and a done Tito. Be serious. JLC looked very unimpressive against Ngoudjo, espicially when you take into consideration the kid had 15 fights. Oh, and where is Miguel Cotto??? How can you say anything about Winky fighting Mosley and Tito, whaen Taylor has fought nothing but blown up jr middles in Ouma and Spinks. Neither one has any power. Instead of fighting legit middleweights than can punch.

if winky aint ur top three ur list is shit

I knew I was missing someone. I have added Kessler.

hey, stop bringing old threads.... jerk. anyway when zab beats cotto, is he in your top 10? No...he might crack the top 20.

1. Winky Wright 2. Floyd Mayweather Jr 3. Manny Pacquiao 4. Rafael Marquez 5. Marco Antonio Barrera 6. Bernard Hopkins 7. Jose Luis Castillo 8. Shane Mosley 9. Joe Calzaghe 10. Juan Manuel Marquez 11. Jermaine Taylor 12. Oscar De La Hoya 13. Joel Casamayor 14. Edison Miranda 15. Chad Dawson I'd buy that for a dollar.

1. Floyd Mayweather Jr. 2. Winky Wright 3. Manny Pacquiao 4. Rafeal Marquez 5. Joe Calzaghe 6. Juan Manuel Marquez 7. Bernard Hopkins 8. Marco Antonio Barrera 9. Joel Casamayor 10. Jose Luis Castillo 11. Shane Mosley 12. Miguel Cotto 13. Ricky Hatton 14. Jermain Taylor 15. Chad Dawson 16. Ivan Calderon 17. Cristian Mijares 18. Oscar De La Hoya 19. Pongsaklek Wonjongkam 20. Juan Diaz

1. Floyd Mayweather, Jr. 2. Joe Calzaghe 3. Manny Pacquiao 4. Rafael Marquez 5. Oscar de la Hoya 6. Jose Luis Castillo 7. Juan Manuel Marquez 8. Wladimir Klitschko 9. Bernard Hopkins 10. Winky Wright 11. Jermain Taylor 12. Joan Guzman 13. Mikkel Kessler 14. Glenn Johnson 15. Miguel Cotto 16. Marco Antonio Barrera 17. Acelino Freitas 18. Carlos Baldomir 19. Ricky Hatton 20. Edison Miranda 21. Edwin Valero 22. Antonio Tarver 23. Joshua Clottey 24. Felix Sturm 25. Chris Byrd Yeah...

I got to agree with you on this one I think Manny Pacquiao is a better P4P fighter than Mayweather.

Floyd Mayweather Jr Manny Pacquiao Rafael Marquez Ronald Wright Joe Calzaghe Jermain Taylor Bernard Hopkins Juan Manuel Marquez Marco Antonio Barrera Ricky Hatton Jose Luis Castillo Shane Mosley Miguel Cotto Joel Casamayor Vic Darchinyan Chad Dawson Ivan Calderon Edison Miranda Arthur Abraham Oscar De La Hoya New list. Arce out....snuck De La Hoya in for good measure. hey, stop bringing old threads.... jerk. anyway when zab beats cotto, is he in your top 10?

Floyd Mayweather Jr Manny Pacquiao Rafael Marquez Ronald Wright Joe Calzaghe Jermain Taylor Bernard Hopkins Juan Manuel Marquez Marco Antonio Barrera Ricky Hatton Jose Luis Castillo Shane Mosley Miguel Cotto Joel Casamayor Mikkel Kessler Vic Darchinyan Chad Dawson Ivan Calderon Edison Miranda Oscar De La Hoya New list. Arce out....snuck De La Hoya in for good measure.

New listing: 1.) Floyd Mayweather Jr 2.) Manny Pacquiao 3.) Rafael Marquez 4.) Ronald Wright 5.) Joe Calzaghe 6.) Jermain Taylor 7.) Bernard Hopkins 8.) Juan Manuel Marquez 9.) Marco Antonio Barrera 10.) Ricky Hatton 11.) Jorge Arce 12.) Jose Luis Castillo 13.) Miguel Cotto 14.) Shane Mosley 15.) Joel Casamayor 16.) Chad Dawson 17.) Ivan Calderon 18.) Vic Darchinyan 19.) Edison Miranda 20.) Arthur Abraham Marquez cracks the top ten, Barrera down 3 slots.

That's pretty good to get 20 fighters together, it's not neccessarily easy to make them in my opininion only I would have Calzaghe in Wright's slot, Darchinyan higher, Pavlik somewhere in the top 20, Cotto somewhere in the top 10, Mosely higher, probably Hatton lower. I think I agree with your top 3. What has Joe done to make himself top 5 p4p in the sport??? What p4p fighters has he faced and beaten??

BTW having Chad Dawson in your top 15/20 is ridiculous. Not as ridiculous as you putting Chris John in yours, but what have you... Dawson just impressively beat (and largely dominated) two very good fighters in Eric Harding and Tomasz Adamek. He has also stopped Ian Gardner and the old vet Carl Daniels. He's one of the best young fighters in the world right now. What do we know about John...? He (by many accounts) controversially beat Juan Manuel Marquez in his own backyard. I think everyone could use more information on this kid before saying he's one of the 20 best fighters in the world.

1.) Floyd Mayweather Jr 2.) Manny Pacquiao 3.) Ronald Wright 4.) Rafael Marquez 5.) Joe Calzaghe 6.) Marco Antonio Barrera 7.) Jermain Taylor 8.) Bernard Hopkins 9.) Ricky Hatton 10.) Jose Luis Castillo 11.) Shane Mosley 12.) Miguel Cotto 13.) Jorge Arce 14.) Joel Casamayor 15.) Vic Darchinyan 16.) Edison Miranda 17.) Ivan Calderon 18.) Juan Manuel Marquez 19.) Chad Dawson 20.) Arthur Abraham

1.Floyd Mayweather Jr. 2.Winky Wright 3.Manny Pacquiao 4.Joe Calzaghe 5.Rafael Marquez 6.Jermain Taylor 7.Marco Antonio Barrera 8.Ricky Hatton 9.Jose Luis Castillo 10.Ivan Calderon 11.Bernard Hopkins 12.Shane Mosley 13.Juan Manuel Marquez 14.Joel Casamayor 15.Miguel Cotto 16.Jorge Arce 17.Joan Guzman 18.Vic Darchinyan 19.Chris John 20.Antonio Margarito

All's I know is Floyd Mayweather Jr. is #1, and Manny Pacquiao is #2. Apart from that it's just too damn hard to try and make a list of them in order.

1.- Winky Wright 2.- Floyd Maywether jr 3.- Manny Pacquiao 4.- Rafael Marquez 5.- Jermaine Taylor 6.- Marco Antonio Barrera 7.- Joe Calzaghe 8.- Bernard Hopkins 9.- Shane Mosley 10.- Jorge Arce 11.- Miguel Cotto 12.- Ricky Hatton 13.- Jose Luis Castillo 14.- Juan Manuel Marquez 15.- Joel Casmayor 16.- Chad Dawson 17.- Israel Vazquez 18.- Ivan Calderon 19.- Edison Miranda 20.- Vic Darchinyan

Pavlik in the top 20??? Give me one reason? He hasnt even faced one middleweight that is ranked in the ring top 10. He's faced some quality fighters like Bronco McKart and some other solid guys and look very impressive against them. Knockout victories. Top 20 worthy.

That's pretty good to get 20 fighters together, it's not neccessarily easy to make them in my opininion only I would have Calzaghe in Wright's slot, Darchinyan higher, Pavlik somewhere in the top 20, Cotto somewhere in the top 10, Mosely higher, probably Hatton lower. I think I agree with your top 3. Pavlik in the top 20??? Give me one reason? He hasnt even faced one middleweight that is ranked in the ring top 10.

I'm bored as sin and I'm recovering from a long night of drinking last night...so why the hell not? 1.) Floyd Mayweather Jr 2.) Manny Pacquiao 3.) Rafael Marquez 4.) Ronald Wright 5.) Marco Antonio Barrera 6.) Joe Calzaghe 7.) Jermain Taylor 8.) Bernard Hopkins 9.) Ricky Hatton 10.) Jorge Arce 11.) Miguel Cotto 12.) Shane Mosley 13.) Joel Casamayor 14.) Jose Luis Castillo 15.) Chad Dawson 16.) Juan Manuel Marquez 17.) Ivan Calderon 18.) Vic Darchinyan 19.) Edison Miranda 20.) Arthur Abraham sure... That's pretty good to get 20 fighters together, it's not neccessarily easy to make them in my opininion only I would have Calzaghe in Wright's slot, Darchinyan higher, Pavlik somewhere in the top 20, Cotto somewhere in the top 10, Mosely higher, probably Hatton lower. I think I agree with your top 3.