Tarver/ Mayweather should not be in the p4p ranking.....

My boy Floyd is ALL P4P and thats the truth. Unbeaten and successful in every fight he has fought. I can't think of a more deserving top P4P ranker out there. As for Tarver he achieved something amazing by knocking out the unstoppable Roy Jones Junior and for that he definatly deserves respect as he was the first man to do it EVER. He should be at the bottom end of the list but in all the same.

Floyed should be in the top 3 or 4 in my opinion. I'd put Kostya Tszyu on the list too but not Tito. Tszyu has been out for 2 years just like Tito but Tszyu is undisputed champ at 140 and Tito hasnt even shown where he stacks up against the other fighters in his division yet. Also Tszyu hasnt lost in a while.

this is definitely true about both fighters.....and true champions are not one-hit wonders.

I love Tito but it is to soon to put him on the list

He's only lost is to the #1 P4P, what more do u need? Yeah, but he took two years off, that knocked him completely off of the list, in my opinion, he needs to earn his way back on to it, and beating Ricardo Mayorga doesn't make him pound for pound worthy, no matter if he only loss to the number 1 fighter..

agreed mate...with his only loss after almost going the distance with the #1p4p he shudn't be counted out of the top 10

i also dont think tito should be in the top 10...only one thing will get him in..and thats beating hopkins (no matter if he has only lost one fight) which dont think he can do i dont think tarver should be considered a p4p just for one big fight floyd deserves it tho in my opioion even though he wont be for long

I couldn't have said it better myself.Two years ago Mayweather was definetly on the top10 p4p list.After barely getting by Castillo without a loss,he's slacked off bigtime.IMO,a Top10 p4p fighter should stay active and should atleast beat another top10 fighter in their weight division.Mayweather has done neither I think Tarver belongs in the top10 p4p,but after Saturday Night Glencoffe Johnson will be knock him off that list and replace him. Alright, let's see your top 10 pound for pound list, and who you have on it.. Cotto is not even closed to be in the Top 10 list yet...Tito should be already in the Top 10 and going up... I don't think Tito Trinidad should be in the top 10. All he beat was Mayorga, was Mayorga even a top 10 p4p when he beat him, and more importantly was he even a Middleweight?

Agree with me or not; I truly believe Antonio tarver should not be in the top 10 p4p boxing list. Though he did ko jones, i just think he hasn't proved his self enough to be qualified for that list. Jones losing about 30 lbs. would make any fighter worse than what the once were. Mayweather should be taken off the list as well. He's not fighting any of the great 140 lb. fighters that's out. So, he's finally going to fight Gatti (if gatti beats leija), but before this fight, he's been looking average. Castillio gave him a run for his money. He fought Corrales, but I think Corrales would hand his ass to him in a rematch. This is just my opinion. I couldn't have said it better myself.Two years ago Mayweather was definetly on the top10 p4p list.After barely getting by Castillo without a loss,he's slacked off bigtime.IMO,a Top10 p4p fighter should stay active and should atleast beat another top10 fighter in their weight division.Mayweather has done neither I think Tarver belongs in the top10 p4p,but after Saturday Night Glencoffe Johnson will be knock him off that list and replace him.

I agree with you that Tarver is not a P4P yet...It's like saying that Johnson should be a P4P cuz he KO jones too. About Floyd he should be at the P4P list, but going down...I still believe that he doesn't belong in the 140 division...And Bruseles might show him that. How do you rank Cotto and Tito? As far as your comment about Johnson, I disagree, because Tarver stopped Roy at the peak of his career (his peak, not prime)..

Anymore it's kinda hard to have a real legit top five fighters in the world. But Mayweather has to be on the list just because of his raw talent. He's only had one fight at 140 and at lower classes he's ether beaten everyone to a pulp or has had them not want to fight him because it would be a sure loss. As for Tarver there's a little more of a case, but he's always been very talented guy, just little talked about untill he kayoed Roy.

As much as I dislike Antonio Tarver, and as big as a Roy Jones Jr. fan I was, I gotta hand it to him...he deserves to be in the top for dethroning the p4p king, however, where G. Leon gets off by putting him at #3 is beyond me.. I think he should be 6 or 5 at best. As far as Mayweather goes, I think he should remain #2. However, I don't like that fact that he wants Gatti so bad that he isn't fighting any of the talent in 140 division, I'm a Mayweather fan regardless of his decision, but after the Gatti fight, I expect for him to up the level of competition, he has no excuse (unlike Roy did in the Light Heavy division, as it was so weak).. As far as Corrales rematch goes, get real, guy.. As much as Chico says he wants a rematch, he doesn't want none.. As far as the Castillo fight goes, it wouldn't be such a big deal to Mayweather haters had he beat him by the margin he usually beats his opponents by. Mayweather clearly won those fights, he just got hit more than he did in any other fight, just like Jones/Tarver I

Agree with me or not; I truly believe Antonio tarver should not be in the top 10 p4p boxing list. Though he did ko jones, i just think he hasn't proved his self enough to be qualified for that list. Jones losing about 30 lbs. would make any fighter worse than what the once were. Mayweather should be taken off the list as well. He's not fighting any of the great 140 lb. fighters that's out. So, he's finally going to fight Gatti (if gatti beats leija), but before this fight, he's been looking average. Castillio gave him a run for his money. He fought Corrales, but I think Corrales would hand his ass to him in a rematch. This is just my opinion. Just because you dont like Floyd dont try to hate. His resume stacks up with anyone's